Zapruder's testimony to the WC = conspiracy

[John Iacoletti]

Try to follow along. Ernie challenged me as to where the shooter could be standing to make a shot. I have never said that the shooter had to be standing; and in fact was either sitting or kneeling in my opinion.

Any opinion on how the incredibly accurate and reliable Howard Brennan saw this guy from the belt up if he was sitting or kneeling at the time of the shot?

[Jerry Freeman]

Steve Barber provided very solid arguments that the HSCA acoustic evidence ?proving? four shots, was highly flawed. 

And I agree... I've always thought that it was really weird to embrace all this acoustic stuff and then  ignore all the other umpteen dozen manifestations of conspiracy

[Bill Chapman]

Any opinion on how the incredibly accurate and reliable Howard Brennan saw this guy from the belt up if he was sitting or kneeling at the time of the shot?

Maybe the shooter had to hitch up his drawers to get that lo

He (your perennial unnamed shooter) was also aiming downrange and pulling the trigger at the time
Are you sure Brennan didn't say 'about' the belt at some point in his testimony?

[John Iacoletti]

Maybe the shooter had to hitch up his drawers to get that lo

Whatever it takes...

He (your perennial unnamed shooter) was also aiming downrange and pulling the trigger at the time

Brennan saw the trigger being pulled?  His eyesight gets better and better with each telling.

Brennan's view of the building as modeled by the "JFK Reloaded" simulation.

[Joffrey van de Wiel]

Whatever it takes...

Brennan saw the trigger being pulled?  His eyesight gets better and better with each telling.

Brennan's view of the building as modeled by the "JFK Reloaded" simulation.

Is this the actual scale? Wow, Brennan had eagles eyes if he was able to recognize Oswald later in the line up, although at first he didn't because he was scared for his family. Is it true that there is no record of Brennan even attending a line-up?

[Royell Storing]

Try to follow along. Ernie challenged me as to where the shooter could be standing to make a shot. I have never said that the shooter had to be standing; and in fact was either sitting or kneeling in my opinion.

Now show me where I did anything other than make the observation that the angle from Brennan's position could make it seem as if the shooter was stepping back from that window.

        Oh I get it. You were making it up.

[Walt Cakebread]

Is this the actual scale? Wow, Brennan had eagles eyes if he was able to recognize Oswald later in the line up, although at first he didn't because he was scared for his family. Is it true that there is no record of Brennan even attending a line-up?

Is it true that there is no record of Brennan even attending a line-up?

There is a record of Brennan attending a line-up.....As I recall he was there at the same time the Davis girls viewed a line-up.

The Detective that escorted the Davis girls noted that Howard Brennan also viewed the line up....

Wow, Brennan had eagles eyes if he was able to recognize Oswald later in the line up,

Brennan DID NOT recognize Lee as the man that he'd seen, who was dressed in light colored khaki clothing, and who was aiming a HUNTING rifle from a sixth floor window.

When Brennan saw the line up he said that Lee most nearly resembled the man that he'd seen.  (Naturally , because the other three didn't come close to matching the description....