Actually, it's not. It's Gerda Dunckel. but it is definitive. Other than that, I decline to be sucked into this, er, "discussion."
Wrong again.
And of course you decline.
You've looked at the case I've put forward in Reply#200 and decided to flee. If there was the slightest weakness in my arguments you would be all over it. It's an intensely cowardly way to approach the arguments.
In front of the forum, you're being ask to outline a potential timeline that explains how Shelley and Lovelady could interact with Gloria, visit the island and then be seen on the extension within 25 - 30 seconds.
It's the simplest thing.
Then you can be on your way.
You have described this identification as "definitive". You need to back this claim up otherwise people might start to get the impression you're just some deluded old man who believes his opinion is fact.