The Tippit Shooting At 1:15-1:16, FACT

[Martin Weidmann]

The problem with your analysis is that Bledsoe could not have seen the hole in the elbow of Oswald's shirt if he was wearing a jacket and Oswald's shirt had a hole in it when he was arrested. He had that same shirt on when he shot JFK because fibers matching that shirt were found on the butt plate of his rifle.

Second problem is why would Oswald wear both jackets. It wasn't that cold in Dallas that morning. You put too much faith in witnesses to tell you whether Oswald was wearing a jacket at any given time. Why would anyone notice that. How many passengers do you think McWatters picked up that day. How many of them do you think he could remember what they were wearing. Why would that even matter to him at the time. Same for Whaley. Oswald was just another fare for him at the time. Why would he even pay attention to what Oswald was wearing. These are just the kind of details witnesses get wrong because at the time they are seeing them, there's no reason for them to even make note of what someone was wearing. If they aren't making a mental note of it at the time, there is no reason to think they could remember it when asked about it later. The hard evidence tells us Oswald wore his blue jacket to work, left it in the TSBD when he fled, picked up his light gray jacket when he went to retrieve his revolver at the rooming house, then ditched it after he shot Tippit.

The problem with your analysis is that Bledsoe could not have seen the hole in the elbow of Oswald's shirt if he was wearing a jacket

Of course she saw it, before her WC testimony, when they brought the shirt Oswald was arrested in to her home and showed it to her.

Mr. BALL - Now, I have got a piece of clothing here, which is marked---
Mrs. BLEDSOE - That is it.
Mr. BALL - Commission Exhibit 150.
Mrs. BLEDSOE - That is it.
Mr. BALL - This is a shirt.
Mrs. BLEDSOE - That is it.
Mr. BALL - What do you mean by "that is it?"
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Because they brought it out to the house and showed it.
Mr. BALL - I know. What do you mean by "that is it?"
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Well, because I can recognize it.
Mr. BALL - Recognize it as what?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Yes, sir; see there?
Mr. BALL - Yes. You tell me what do you see here? What permits you to recognize it?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - I recognize---first thing I notice the elbow is out and then I saw---when the man brought it out and let me see it?
Mr. BALL - No, I am talking about---I am showing you this shirt now, and you said, "That is it." You mean---What do you mean by "that is it"?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - That is the one he had out there that day?
Mr. BALL - Who had it out there?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Some Secret Service man.

And this is where she gives up the game;

Mr. BALL - He brought it out. Now, I am---you have seen this shirt then before?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Yes.
Mr. BALL - It was brought out by the Secret Service man and shown to you?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Yes.
Mr. BALL - Had you ever seen the shirt before that?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Well---
Mr. BALL - Have you?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - No; he had it on, though.

She saw Oswald wearing the shirt "before he was shot".

Mr. BALL - Who had it on?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Oswald.
Mr. BALL - Oswald had it on?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Oswald had it on.
Mr. BALL - Now, what is there about the shirt that makes you believe that this is the shirt that Oswald had on when he was on the bus? What is there about it?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Well, let's see the front of it. Yes See all this [indicating]? I remember that.
Mr. BALL - Tell me what you see there?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - I saw the---no; not so much that. It was done after---that is part I recognize more than anything.
Mr. BALL - You are pointing to a hole in the right elbow?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Yes.
Mr. BALL - What about the color?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Well, I---What do you mean?
Mr. BALL - Well----
Mrs. BLEDSOE - When he had it on?
Mr. BALL - Yes.
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Before he was shot? Yes; I remember it being brown.

Bledsoe was all over the place and her testimony has no corroboration. She saw Oswald wear the shirt after he was arrested and before he was shot.
She recognized the shirt from when it was shown to her at her home.

He had that same shirt on when he shot JFK because fibers matching that shirt were found on the butt plate of his rifle.

 

[Bill Brown]

A. Earlene Roberts  described Oswald as wearing a long sleeve shirt when he entered the boarding room. (She couldn’t tell what color)  She said Oswald left the room wearing and zipping up a jacket which appeared to her darker than CE 162 the light gray jacket.(still could not tell what color).

B. Since CE 163, the Blue gray jacket was allegedly found in the Domino room albeit unknown whom found it, then either Oswald left CE 163 there or it was moved there a month later for some unknown reason.

C. Frazier describes Oswald wearing a jacket that was similar to the CE 162 light gray jacket to work on Friday.

D. McWatters the bus driver, said he saw the man to whom the bus transfer ticket was given, wearing a jacket.  McWatters was not asked about the color of the jacket.

E. Whaley the taxi driver said he thought Oswald was wearing a jacket but what the color was could be either jacket.

F. Bledsoe said she was on McWatters bus and saw Oswald wearing the brown shirt with the hole in the sleeve.

A thru E can be reconciled as supporting a proposition that Oswald wore CE 162 to work Friday, then left TSBD Friday wearing it , then wore it  on McWatters bus , wore it in Whaleys taxi and then Oswald  entered the boarding house wearing it and finally left his room STILL wearing it and zipping it up.

Bledsoe cannot be reconciled at all with these other witnesses therefore  she must be mistaken or she just wanted to claim she saw the hole because she already despised Oswald from previous experience as his landlady.

Thus the solution for the Blue Jacket found in the Domino Room may be that Oswald wore Both CE163 the Blue gray jacket and CE 162 light gray jacket to work on Thursday morning and left CE 163 in the Domino room on Thursday afternoon. Oswald wore just CE 162 when he got the ride with Frazier Thursday afternoon.

E. Whaley the taxi driver said he thought Oswald was wearing a jacket but what the color was could be either jacket.

Months before his Warren Commission testimony, no mention of a jacket....

[Michael Capasse]

Recall this to me in the jury room and she is OUT:

Mr. BALL - He brought it out. Now, I am---you have seen this shirt then before?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Yes.

Mr. BALL - It was brought out by the Secret Service man and shown to you?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Yes.

Mr. BALL - Had you ever seen the shirt before that?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - Well---

Mr. BALL - Have you?
Mrs. BLEDSOE - No; he had it on, though.

[Zeon Mason]

Months before rhis Warren Commission testimony, no mention of a jacket....

That last couple of sentences looks like to me the description of the man as 5ft 8in , slender wearing a dark shirt and white pants? And he was wearing a bracelet ?

Whaley repeated the bracelet detail in his WC testimony.

Bill do you know what the time was when Whaley wrote that statement?

Because if he wrote that statement before he saw any TV camera recordings or pictures of Oswald in newspapers then imo that bracelet detail supports that Whaley saw Oswald.

If however if the statement was written after Oswald was seen by millions holding up his hands handcuffed with the bracelet clearly visible, then given the discrepancy of Whaleys WC testimony about seeing a jacket, would that cast some reasonable doubt if he even ever had Oswald in the taxi at all?

[Bill Brown]

That last couple of sentences looks like to me the description of the man as 5ft 8in , slender wearing a dark shirt and white pants? And he was wearing a bracelet ?

Whaley repeated the bracelet detail in his WC testimony.

Bill do you know what the time was when Whaley wrote that statement?

Because if he wrote that statement before he saw any TV camera recordings or pictures of Oswald in newspapers then imo that bracelet detail supports that Whaley saw Oswald.

If however if the statement was written after Oswald was seen by millions holding up his hands handcuffed with the bracelet clearly visible, then given the discrepancy of Whaleys WC testimony about seeing a jacket, would that cast some reasonable doubt if he even ever had Oswald in the taxi at all?

Whaley attended the lineup on Saturday afternoon around 2:15 p.m.

He wrote this statement shortly after viewing the lineup.  So.....2:30 ish

[Michael Capasse]

I don't believe he WROTE that statement.
I think he had limited ability to read and write.

  No mention of a jacket? So what. They didn't asked him.