Dead Oswald Tour

[Martin Weidmann]

Anybody could claim that they were in their car at that time.  Not at all surprised that Chapman is willing to just take somebody's word for it, as long as they say what he likes.
_I have no reason to call Tatum a liar

One can see in the video that Benavides had no doubt that he could ID Oswald
I also have no reason to call him a liar.

Mr. BELIN - Did he ever take you to the police station and ask you if you could identify him?
Mr. BENAVIDES - No; they didn't.
_So what?
 

The desperation by which you fight against the odds to keep your little fairytale fantasy alive is hilarious.

You really need to take a step back and ask yourself just how many people are in jail right now for a crime they did not commit, because of flawed eye-witness testimony and/or prosecutorial misconduct. Especially in Texas the track record of one Henry Wade is extremely poor. Just ask Barry Scheck

https://innocenceproject.org/all-cases/

[Martin Weidmann]

Aha! So you do find the Patton Ground Zero witness testimonies meaningless!
Once again, thanks so much for your always-useful posts.

Aha! So you do find the Patton Ground Zero witness testimonies meaningless!

Where did I say that?

Couldn't you even figure out that the clown and his meaningless silliness I was talking about was you? Oh boy...

You really are a confused puppy.....

[Bill Chapman]

The desperation by which you fight against the odds to keep your little fairytale fantasy alive is hilarious.

You really need to take a step back and ask yourself just how many people are in jail right now for a crime they did not commit, because of flawed eye-witness testimony and/or prosecutorial misconduct. Especially in Texas the track record of one Henry Wade is extremely poor. Just ask Barry Scheck

https://innocenceproject.org/all-cases/

Appeal to Authority

And you are practically dismissing the Patton Ground Zero witnesses as liars

Oswald wouldn't qualify for TIP help
Too many 'eyes on' at Patton

[Bill Chapman]

Aha! So you do find the Patton Ground Zero witness testimonies meaningless!

Where did I say that?

Couldn't you even figure out that the clown and his meaningless silliness I was talking about was you? Oh boy...

You really are a confused puppy.....

Hey Chucky, tell us what's 'silly' about posting witness statements

[Martin Weidmann]

Appeal to Authority

And you are practically dismissing the Patton Ground Zero witnesses as liars

Oswald wouldn't qualify for TIP help
Too many 'eyes on' at Patton

Appeal to Authority

Which only tells me you don't understand the fallacy. People being released from wrongful conviction is factual.

And you are practically dismissing the Patton Ground Zero witnesses as liars

Am I?

Why can't they be just as mistaken as all the other witnesses the WC dismissed as mistaken?

Oswald wouldn't qualify for TIP help

He might not need it. A good mathematician would be enough.

Too many 'eyes on' at Patton

That's an appeal to majority fallacy

[Martin Weidmann]

Hey Chucky, tell us what's 'silly' about posting witness statements

You need to ask?

[John Iacoletti]

_I have no reason to call Tatum a liar

Of course you don't.  He says what you want to hear.  You have no reason to call Acquilla Clemons or Doris Holan a liar either.

One can see in the video that Benavides had no doubt that he could ID Oswald

Why should I care more about what Benavides said 3 years later than what he said on 11/22/63?  Oh yeah, because it's what you want to hear.