Oswald in the TSBD just after the shooting

[Oscar Navarro]

This analysis is for any members who are here to "discuss and debate" the assassination. I would hope that those who read this can appreciate the time and effort that goes into the sourcing and analysis of the official documents on which it is based. For those of you who wish to engage and offer an opinion feel free to do so.

I would offer the following two statements for consideration.

Bonnie Ray Williams provided a written statement to the DPD, on the day of the assassination, that described his movements prior to the arrival of the motorcade that was essentially consistent with the statements provided Jarman and Norman prior to their appearance before the WC. Agree or disagree?

Williams went to the 6th floor to eat his lunch and watch the motorcade prior to joining Jarman and Norman on the 5th floor on the day of the assassination. Agree or disagree?

Who is up for "discussion and debate"?

OK, let's discuss and debate. I think BRW had no reason to lie and neither did Jarman and Norman. I have posted my opinion on the subject already. The totality of all the statements of the Three Amigos (sounds much better than The Three Stooges) were covered in their testimonies before the Commission. I think relying on Arnold Rowland's testimony is foolish. I agree with your following statement "Williams went to the 6th floor to eat his lunch and watch the motorcade prior to joining Jarman and Norman on the 5th floor on the day of the assassination. Agree or disagree?" I won't be able to fully engage until Thursday night at the earliest as I have some commitments.

[Colin Crow]

OK, let's discuss and debate. I think BRW had no reason to lie and neither did Jarman and Norman. I have posted my opinion on the subject already. The totality of all the statements of the Three Amigos (sounds much better than The Three Stooges) were covered in their testimonies before the Commission. I think relying on Arnold Rowland's testimony is foolish. I agree with your following statement "Williams went to the 6th floor to eat his lunch and watch the motorcade prior to joining Jarman and Norman on the 5th floor on the day of the assassination. Agree or disagree?" I won't be able to fully engage until Thursday night at the earliest as I have some commitments.

Thanks Oscar. What about the first statement? Was Williams handwritten first day statement consistent with what Jarman and Norman indicated prior to their appearances before the WC? Does it indicate that he went downstairs for lunch then went up with them to the fifth floor just before the assassination? Yes or no?

[Peter Kleinschmidt]

Juan Jose Castro.... A close relative of Fidel..... 

C'mon.....What pat of "imaginary" don't you understand?    I invented that scenario to demonstrate that it's possible that Lee was given the gun in the Theater....

Well, if LHO was set-up, of course, he would have to of been directed to the theater to unknowingly meet a zillion officers for what, not paying the admission?  Instead, they should have sent LHO to Ruth Paine's neighbor. Sure, it's miles away but if Lee can do all these impossible tasks you just create another impossible feat.
Getting back to your revolver idea. He had before he left the DSBD. I don't understand why he stopped by the boardinghouse, involved or not, that is the last place I would go

[Walt Cakebread]

Well, if LHO was set-up, of course, he would have to of been directed to the theater to unknowingly meet a zillion officers for what, not paying the admission?  Instead, they should have sent LHO to Ruth Paine's neighbor. Sure, it's miles away but if Lee can do all these impossible tasks you just create another impossible feat.
Getting back to your revolver idea. He had before he left the DSBD. I don't understand why he stopped by the boardinghouse, involved or not, that is the last place I would go

Getting back to your revolver idea. He had before he left the DSBD. I don't understand why he stopped by the boardinghouse, involved or not, that is the last place I would go

The imaginary dialog took place IN the Texas Theater AFTER Lee left the rooming house.....  Are you aware that there were three of Hoover's men in the Texas Theater at the time Lee was dragged from the theater.....  Imagine that... Federal agents pursuing someone who had sneaked into a theater!

[Peter Kleinschmidt]

Getting back to your revolver idea. He had before he left the DSBD. I don't understand why he stopped by the boardinghouse, involved or not, that is the last place I would go

The imaginary dialog took place IN the Texas Theater AFTER Lee left the rooming house.....  Are you aware that there were three of Hoover's men in the Texas Theater at the time Lee was dragged from the theater.....  Imagine that... Federal agents pursuing someone who had sneaked into a theater!

Yes, but I'm starting to think I was there too.
Why would they be right in the theater, when they could have watched from a distance. When people talk "conspiracy" in general I would have to imagine it is the reason evidence is always in layers as if the conspiracy involved certain agencies by accident or after the fact.

[Walt Cakebread]

Yes, but I'm starting to think I was there too.
Why would they be right in the theater, when they could have watched from a distance. When people talk "conspiracy" in general I would have to imagine it is the reason evidence is always in layers as if the conspiracy involved certain agencies by accident or after the fact.

Why would they be right in the theater, when they could have watched from a distance.

I'm not going to give you the answer.... It doesn't take a genius to arrive at a plausible answer to that question....Think about it.

[Rob Caprio]

Name the 'multiple' witnesses
And where did your 'Oswald' wind up?

You still don't know the evidence, huh?