Et tu, Bonnie?

[Colin Crow]

This is too easy: I give precise directions to where I know all this leads (look down, look way down), and your response arrives in the form of yet another CT 'waste of space' nothingburger.

You claimed Jerry Organ had an amazing graphic showing reconstruction of the bag. I found something. Was that it? I did ask you for a link.

The documents available to the WC show seven officers reporting the chicken lunch in the SN prior to the arrival of Fritz. Yet the Report claimed it was found at least two isles westward? Why?

The LN script is unmovable to the regurgitators. Nothing can shift or it falls apart for you. At least John Mytton was smart enough to get Oswald back into the SN and maintain Oswald as LN.

Comic relief is supposed to be humerous at least. Keep trying.

[Richard Smith]

Dan, some time back I researched the chicken lunch issue. This was independent of Don Thomas. You would have noticed the snide remarks about my research from Richard the regurgitator and Bill the comic relief in this thread. The following officers described remnants on the lunch in the SN prior to the arrival of Fritz, Mooney, McCurley, Boone, Faulkner, Craig, Hill, Brewer, Haywood and Weatherford.

Jim Ewell, a news reporter who had travelled to the TSBD with Jerry Hill, later related in No More Silence that Hill held up the chicken bone and hollered to those below that the fried chicken was what the assassin had been eating.

Richard and Bill won’t engage in discussion of the evidence because they know where it leads.

Colin-  I give you lots of credit for actually researching and trying to support your conclusions.  That places you well beyond the average contrarian or CTer who posts here without ever doing so or suggesting that they don't have to prove anything as though they are Oswald's lawyer in a criminal trial.  But it makes the conclusions that you reach no less outlandish.  There is no mystery about the chicken sandwich or BRW.   He explained his lunch and movements.  His language and recollections are perhaps not scientifically precise about every event that took place that day (many of which would have been mundane at the time they occurred) but that is no basis to reach any outlandish conclusions about what was motivating BRW's actions.  To suggest this individual saw the assassin (Oswald or otherwise), was allowed to leave the floor by this gunman, decided to say or do nothing about this notable event, and instead move down to the windows directly below where he had reason to believe someone was getting ready to shoot the President, and then forever remain silent just doesn't add up as a plausible narrative without even getting into the complete absence of any evidence of such.   It does lead to one of my favorite question and answer sessions in the WC, though:

Mr. BALL. What did you have in your lunch?
Mr. WILLIAMS. I had a chicken sandwich.
Mr. BALL. Describe the sandwich. What did it have in it besides chicken?
Mr. WILLIAMS. Well, it just had chicken in it. Chicken on the bone.
Mr. BALL. Chicken on the bone?
Mr. WILLIAMS. Yes.
Mr. BALL. The chicken was not boned?
Mr. WILLIAMS. It was just chicken on the bone. Just plain old chicken.
Mr. BALL. Did it have bread around it?
Mr. WILLIAMS. Yes, it did.

[Bill Chapman]

You claimed Jerry Organ had an amazing graphic showing reconstruction of the bag. I found something. Was that it? I did ask you for a link.

The documents available to the WC show seven officers reporting the chicken lunch in the SN prior to the arrival of Fritz. Yet the Report claimed it was found at least two isles westward? Why?

The LN script is unmovable to the regurgitators. Nothing can shift or it falls apart for you. At least John Mytton was smart enough to get Oswald back into the SN and maintain Oswald as LN.

Comic relief is supposed to be numerous at least. Keep trying.

LOL.

So you have to recruit an LN in an attempt to justify your pet theory. Well, that speaks volumes.

And where did I say Jerry Organ had 'an amazing construction of the bag'? I said he was the guy to demonstrate the construction of the bag. And why exactly does 'comic relief' have to be 'numerous'haha.

Back to Jerry Organ: While you brainiacs detract and waste time fussing about the ends of a 38" bag (into which a 34.8" curtain rod/sandwich/or any other 34.8" object fits nicely), Mr Organ has shown exactly how the bag can be carried to minimize said bag's profile.

[Colin Crow]

Colin-  I give you lots of credit for actually researching and trying to support your conclusions.  That places you well beyond the average contrarian or CTer who posts here without ever doing so or suggesting that they don't have to prove anything as though they are Oswald's lawyer in a criminal trial.  But it makes the conclusions that you reach no less outlandish.  There is no mystery about the chicken sandwich or BRW.   He explained his lunch and movements.  His language and recollections are perhaps not scientifically precise about every event that took place that day (many of which would have been mundane at the time they occurred) but that is no basis to reach any outlandish conclusions about what was motivating BRW's actions.  To suggest this individual saw the assassin (Oswald or otherwise), was allowed to leave the floor by this gunman, decided to say or do nothing about this notable event, and instead move down to the windows directly below where he had reason to believe someone was getting ready to shoot the President, and then forever remain silent just doesn't add up as a plausible narrative without even getting into the complete absence of any evidence of such.   It does lead to one of my favorite question and answer sessions in the WC, though:

Mr. BALL. What did you have in your lunch?
Mr. WILLIAMS. I had a chicken sandwich.
Mr. BALL. Describe the sandwich. What did it have in it besides chicken?
Mr. WILLIAMS. Well, it just had chicken in it. Chicken on the bone.
Mr. BALL. Chicken on the bone?
Mr. WILLIAMS. Yes.
Mr. BALL. The chicken was not boned?
Mr. WILLIAMS. It was just chicken on the bone. Just plain old chicken.
Mr. BALL. Did it have bread around it?
Mr. WILLIAMS. Yes, it did.

Something to ponder. We are supposed to believe BRW sat in anticipation of seeing the Presidential motorcade for 15 minutes or so on the sixth floor. Not knowing exactly when it would pass. All that time behind a dirty closed window. When he does go down to the 5th, he opens one.

I don’t know what made him leave the SN so late. I can’t explain exactly why several officers would describe chicken outside the bag when Studebaker claimed it was all inside. Seems to me someone "tidied" the bones into the bag early on and dropped it a couple of windows over (Hill). No conspiracy just incompetence in handling a crime scene. Then CYA.....no CIA.

What I do know is Williams, Jarman, Norman and Givens all provided contradictory statements. Jarman and Norman in particular attempted to mislead by claiming Williams ascended with them. These earlier statements were never challenged or raised by the WC lawyers during testimony.

[Colin Crow]

It's ok I found this myself. You obviously had more important posts to reply to. Is it what you were referring to?



Not much detail about how the 2 inches of open end secure the stock from poking through. Nice cartoon though, always good for a laugh.

Was this the Organ construction you referred to Bill. I never got a reply to my request for a link. You reference it again but provide nothing. At least you're consistent.

PS numerous was supposed to be humorous, apple generated typo. You got in before I edited.

PPS As I said, JohnM was at least open to the evidence presented. He was able to maintain his LN belief. We both agreed Williams likely saw the assassin.

[Alan J. Ford]

He truly didn't remember

We know it wasn't when Roy Truly accompanied Chief Lumpkin upstairs to tell Captain Fritz the wrongly-accused was missing, because by then the entire 6th floor was covered by law-enforcement...leaving even the superintendent himself limited access.

So, that time-interval is out, leaving us wondering just when was Roy Truly privy to the sniper's nest--his words, not mine ---->

Mr. BELIN. When did you get over to the southeast corner of the sixth floor?
Mr. TRULY. That I can't answer. I don't remember when I went over there. It was sometime before I learned that they had found either the rifle or the spent shell cases.

While he was privy to the sniper's nest before the incriminating evidence was found means he had ample opportunity to plant "evidence".

Save for his Freudian Slip--perhaps due to age and/or fatigue--we wouldn't have known Roy Truly was even in the sniper's nest before the incriminating evidence was found.  The prevailing questions now is when was Roy Truly in the sniper's nest...and what was he doing there? and why?

[Bill Chapman]

Was this the Organ construction you referred to Bill. I never got a reply to my request for a link. You reference it again but provide nothing. At least you're consistent.

PS numerous was supposed to be humorous, apple generated typo. You got in before I edited.

PPS As I said, JohnM was at least open to the evidence presented. He was able to maintain his LN belief. We both agreed Williams likely saw the assassin.

Not given his testifying that from his vantage point he could only see the top of the windows of the sn.

And I did not refer to any specific Organ graphic. I should have said 'go-to guy' I suppose... based on the high quality of his work. The Organ graphic here is obviously about the actual carrying position, not a deconstruction of the bag itself. More importantly a 34.8" sized object still fits into a 38" bag where I come from, no matter how much one wants to fantasize about the bag being built for a 27" mystery object.