Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Author Topic: Video: Dan Rather and Gerald Posner analyze the shots that killed JFK  (Read 106 times)

Offline Duncan MacRae

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 648
    • JFK Assassination Photographs
Video: Dan Rather and Gerald Posner analyze the shots that killed JFK


Online John Corbett

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2126
One thing I didn't like about Posner is that in promoting his book, he pushed the myth that the WC had concluded Oswald fired his 3 shots in under 6 seconds and that he was somehow correcting the record. The WCR needed no corrections. The scenario Posner proposed fell within the parameters stated by the WCR. I don't know if he did this by ignorance or deliberate deceit, but either way he was just plain wrong.

Online Steve M. Galbraith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1961
In "Case Closed", Posner presents this scenario of the shooting. He has the first shot at Z160-166 and the last at Z313. That's ~150 frames or about 8 seconds (150/18). It's a little fuzzy so you might want to magnify.


Online Royell Storing

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5602


   Very strange that during this entire presentation, there was NO MENTION of Rather's CBS broadcasts the weekend of the JFK Assassination. The same broadcasts where Rather described viewing a different Zapruder Film than the Zapruder Film that was used for this presentation.

Online John Corbett

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2126
Dan Rather is, was, and always will be a damn liar. The WC never conclude Oswald fired all three shots in under 6 seconds. Posner embraced the same lie in his effort to make it seem that he was setting the record straight. The WC always allowed for the possibility that Oswald took more than 6 seconds to fire his three shots. They found that Oswald fired 3 shots missing JFK with one of those shots but never came to a conclusion as to which of the 3 shots was the miss. The determined that there was no more than 5.6 seconds between the 2 shots that hit JFK and it's only the second shot miss scenario that would require Oswald to fire all 3 shots in 5.6 seconds or less. The reality is there were about 4.9 seconds between the two hits and the missed shot came before those 2 shots. We are able to determine that due to decades of time, millions of eyeballs viewing the Z-film, and technology that wasn't available to the WC.

It will forever be a black mark on Walter Cronkite, Dan Rather, and the entire CBS News organization for having propagated this lie for all these years. Either it was a deliberate lie or extremely sloppy journalism that led them to this conclusion. All they would have had to do to know this wasn't true would be to read the conclusion summary at the end of the chapter that dealt with the 3 shots.
« Last Edit: Yesterday at 04:45:26 PM by John Corbett »

Online Royell Storing

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 5602
Dan Rather is, was, and always will be a damn liar. The WC never conclude Oswald fired all three shots in under 6 seconds. Posner embraced the same lie in his effort to make it seem that he was setting the record straight. The WC always allowed for the possibility that Oswald took more than 6 seconds to fire his three shots. They found that Oswald fired 3 shots missing JFK with one of those shots but never came to a conclusion as to which of the 3 shots was the miss. The determined that there was no more than 5.6 seconds between the 2 shots that hit JFK and it's only the second shot miss scenario that would require Oswald to fire all 3 shots in 5.6 seconds or less. The reality is there were about 4.9 seconds between the two hits and the missed shot came before those 2 shots. We are able to determine that due to decades of time, millions of eyeballs viewing the Z-film, and technology that wasn't available to the WC.

It will forever be a black mark on Walter Cronkite, Dan Rather, and the entire CBS News organization for having propagated this lie for all these years. Either it was a deliberate lie or extremely sloppy journalism that led them to this conclusion. All they would have had to do to know this wasn't true would be to read the conclusion summary at the end of the chapter that dealt with the 3 shots.

    Your clan would be wise to take it easy on Rather. You tick him off and he will again tell the World what he saw on the Z Film Copy he viewed the weekend of the assassination.
    Rather carries a "Get Outta Jail Free" card. He can Say and Do whatever he wants. Get whatever he wants too. Like Cronkite's chair. Posner? He's Arnold Horshack trying to get attention by glomming onto Dan Rather. Just like Max Holland did with National Geographic. These are Not stand alone individuals nor are the theories they ballyhoo. They are distributing pure "Pulp Fiction".

Online Jarrett Smith

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 244
Posner is garbage. Mr. Oswald didn’t know Ferrie, and lied about Boswell.