Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Users Currently Browsing This Topic:
Brian Doyle, Tom Graves, Mark Ulrik

Author Topic: Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?  (Read 158 times)

Online John Corbett

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1670
I've only been a regular on this board for about 6 months so maybe some of the new names I'm seeing lately have been here before, but if so it was before I joined. I'm guessing from what I've read in other threads is that the Ed Forum has killed their JFKA discussion group and that some of those regulars are making a new home here. Not that I have any objection to that. It does seem that most of the unfamiliar names are CTs and they bring a whole new kind of nuttiness. The more the merrier.

Online Dan Rice

  • Subscriber
  • *
  • Posts: 2
Re: Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?
« Reply #1 on: Yesterday at 06:42:24 PM »
I'm a member of the Ed Forum.  I registered here when it looked like the Ed Forum might disappear.  I don't post much there as I defer to those with much more knowledge than me.  But I do like check the posts there regularly.  And I regularly check in here, as well.

Online Brian Doyle

  • Subscriber
  • *
  • Posts: 16
Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?
« Reply #2 on: Yesterday at 06:55:30 PM »

The Education Forum has always created exiles due to its draconian, unaccountable moderation...The members there know what the deal is and knuckle under to the overbearing moderation with sycophancy and obsequiousness...The Deep Politics Forum was formed as a sanctuary to excessive Education Forum moderation...

In my opinion a poster's status should be determined by the quality of his research...This is something that has been corrupted on The Education Forum in to controlling members having their way and giving right of way to their favorites...In my case I accuse The Education Forum of using censorship and banning to avoid the correct evidence on Prayer Man and forcing what they know to be the incorrect evidence...This is so bad that it invalidates the forum...The way the forum deals with this accusation is to ban and ignore those who try to show it...

Online Lance Payette

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1671
Re: Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?
« Reply #3 on: Yesterday at 07:38:46 PM »
I don't post much there as I defer to those with much more knowledge than me.

That used to be my attitude, too. "Wow, these people know EVERYTHING about the JFKA! I am unworthy." You might do as I did: pick a couple of their claims and check them out for yourself. You may well find that an awful lot of what they "know" isn't "knowledge" by a long shot. Or that they know an awful lot of stuff that they try to fit into a JFKA narrative but doesn't really belong there. Even better, invent an absolutely wacky conspiracy claim out of thin air - "Ruth Paine had been Hosty's mistress for three years before the JFKA" - and see how many people immediately agree with you and take it to new heights of lunacy.

Online John Corbett

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1670
Re: Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?
« Reply #4 on: Yesterday at 11:29:43 PM »
At least ten years ago, probably more, I was encouraged to join the Ed Forum by one of its members. I did try but was unsuccessful. As best I remember it, I was told they were not accepting new members at the time. Based on some of the comments I've read, that was no great loss for me. I probably would have been too blunt for their liking anyway.

Online Tom Graves

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3838
Re: Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?
« Reply #5 on: Yesterday at 11:44:32 PM »
The Education Forum has always created exiles due to its draconian, unaccountable moderation...The members there know what the deal is and knuckle under to the overbearing moderation with sycophancy and obsequiousness...The Deep Politics Forum was formed as a sanctuary to excessive Education Forum moderation...

In my opinion a poster's status should be determined by the quality of his research...This is something that has been corrupted on The Education Forum in to controlling members having their way and giving right of way to their favorites...In my case I accuse The Education Forum of using censorship and banning to avoid the correct evidence on Prayer Man and forcing what they know to be the incorrect evidence...This is so bad that it invalidates the forum...The way the forum deals with this accusation is to ban and ignore those who try to show it...

Former Ed Forum moderator Kathy Beckett and a far-left, Nosenko-loving / Bagley-hating firebwand CT by the name of Michael Clark conspired to kick me out of the so-called JFK Assassination Debate - Education Forum in May 2018.
« Last Edit: Today at 01:01:48 AM by Tom Graves »

Online Tom Scully

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1248
Re: Is this forum being invaded by refugees from the Ed Forum?
« Reply #6 on: Today at 01:04:53 AM »
Former Ed Forum moderator Kathy Beckett and a far-left, Nosenko-loving / Bagley-hating firebwand CT by the name of Michael Clark conspired to kick me out of the so-called JFK Assassination Debate - Education Forum in May 2018.

"It was long ago and far away, and so much better than it is today"

My advice, wear slippers, I inadvertently stepped on the wrong folks' toes.

I was removed from the Ed Forum by John Simkin in 2013 for the offense of making Simkin's book author friend, Peter Janney, look ridiculous.
I really pissed off Janney's Budd, Doug Horne, as well. Janney's aunt was married to Rockefeller sponsored ,
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Pace

And Janney's father was Personnel Director of the CIA
Quote
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Wistar_Morris_Janney
Frederick Wistar Morris Janney (March 15, 1919 – January 18, 1979) was a career Central Intelligence Agency officer who was recruited by Allen Dulles in 1949. He held a number of positions during his thirty-year career and was awarded the Agency's highest honor, the Distinguished Intelligence Medal, four days after his death.[1]

Quote
https://www.google.com/books/edition/Mary_s_Mosaic/OGOCDwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=mary%27s+mosaic+dieugenio+protege&pg=PT348&printsec=frontcover
Mary's Mosaic: The CIA Conspiracy to Murder John F. Kennedy, ...
books.google.com › books
Peter Janney · 2016
Found inside
... DiEugenio protégé whose name, I discovered, was Tom Scully, but he would identify himself on Amazon only as “Rational Voice.” Discussing his critical post of Mary's Mosaic in an email to a University of Georgia law professor, Scully ...

Doug Horne's review of the first edition of Janney's book that had to be rewritten to attempt to make3 it less ridiculous,
https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R8NNVIZE9ITM/ref=cm_cr_othr_d_rvw_ttl?ie=UTF8&ASIN=1510708928

Doug Horne's reaction to my Amazon review of his friend, Janney's book.:

Douglas Horne's reaction to facts he was unable to refute but did not appreciate learning of, to say the least!

Quote
Douglas 13 years ago In reply to an earlier post Report abuse

If you are a truly "rational voice" you will provide your real name and tell us exactly how you came by your citations. To not do so is cowardly. To continue not to do so will make readers wonder who you really represent, and really work for. Are you a third party surrogate (or a direct employee) working for the USG whose mission here is to attempt to discredit the confession of a hit-man? The readers of your book review here will not have forgotten that William L. Mitchell (or someone identifying himself as this person) confessed to author Leo Damore---William L. Mitchell himself told Damore that he was Mary Meyer's murderer. This event is well-documented in Janney's book.

Your attempt to suggest otherwise, via your citations, conveniently ignores this vital fact. Peter Janney has not identified Mitchell as Meyer's murderer "because Mitchell could not be found," as you claim; rather, he has identified Mitchell as Meyer's murderer because Mitchell confessed this to Damore. All the citations in the world will not erase this fact.

Your citations seem to me like the kind of detailed biographical information that would be maintained by the same "outfit" that would have maintained Mitchell's operational file at the Agency. Who the hell else would know these things? What ordinary reader would have the ability to look up and find the citations you so conveniently found?

If the William L. Mitchell you cite did not kill Mary Meyer in 1964, then perhaps his identity was highjacked---stolen---circa 1964, by the covert operations ("wet") arm of the Agency---and used by the hitman.

Unless you provide us with your real name and the exact means by which you came up with your citations, you will only increase everyone's suspicion of your motivations here---and your methods.

Many despicable and cold-blooded people throughout history have been well-educated. So finding a person named William L. Mitchell with three college degrees does not prove he could not have been Mary Meyer's killer. That seems like the kind of flawed "logic" an intelligence agency would use on readers in an attempt to cast doubt about the disturbing conclusions of a controversial book.

If this William L. Mitchell didn't kill Mary Meyer, why isn't he raising hell about Janney's book? We certainly haven't heard a peep from him, now, have we?

Why don't you "get real" and tell us who you are, and how you found your citations? What tools did you use? Did someone lead you to them? Did someone provide them to you? Your postings have the odor to me of a disinformation/spin operation, designed to cast doubt, and to make readers forget the basic fact that a "William L. Mitchell" confessed to murdering Mary Meyer for the CIA, to author Leo Damore. Attorney Jimmy Smith's notes of his phone call with Leo Damore prove that.
« Last Edit: Today at 01:26:14 AM by Tom Scully »