JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion & Debate > JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion And Debate

Oswald's strange behaviour and lies regarding the long brown paper rifle bag.

<< < (4/4)

Benjamin Cole:
JC-

The HSCA may have not been perfect, but they were staffed up, and Robert Blakey was reasonable and intelligent man (with whom I have traded e-mails).

The actual House Representatives on the HSCA did not seem to add much, although most had law degrees and what not, and were likely a relatively intelligent group. (I am the first to assent that public office-holder quality has declined in the last 40 years).

As for the acoustics evidence, I never could make head nor tails of any of it.

I can see the Z-film, frame by frame, and make my own layman's analysis.

The acoustics stuff----click sounds on a tape?

Some experts say they are important and others say they are not important.

I have no idea.

John Corbett:

--- Quote from: Benjamin Cole on April 20, 2026, 03:56:09 AM ---JC-

The HSCA may have not been perfect, but they were staffed up, and Robert Blakey was reasonable and intelligent man (with whom I have traded e-mails).

--- End quote ---
I'm sure Robert Blakey was intelligent and just as sure he got duped.

--- Quote ---
The actual House Representatives on the HSCA did not seem to add much, although most had law degrees and what not, and were likely a relatively intelligent group. (I am the first to assent that public office-holder quality has declined in the last 40 years).

--- End quote ---
I don't know that it has ever been top drawer. I think ambition more than intelligence directs people to seek public office.

--- Quote ---
As for the acoustics evidence, I never could make head nor tails of any of it.

--- End quote ---
It was never scrutinized and didn't survive peer review. I think it was Steve Barber who noticed the crosstalk from the other channel and concluded the recording was made after the assassination.

--- Quote ---
I can see the Z-film, frame by frame, and make my own layman's analysis.

The acoustics stuff----click sounds on a tape?

Some experts say they are important and others say they are not important.

I have no idea.

--- End quote ---
I do. The supposed acoustics evidence is not a recording of the shooting. It has been dunked every which way. Dale Myers proved through film and still photos that the motorcycle that was believed to have had the stuck open transmitter was not where the acoustics team said it had to be for their findings to be valid. It was junk science dumped on the HSCA at the 11rh hour that was never given the scrutiny it should have been  given it was the primary basis for the HSCA's conclusion of a fourth shot, a second gunman, and a conspiracy.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page