How did Oswald get the job at the TSBD

[Martin Weidmann]

They are not in disagreement. They are only in disagreement if you assume that Shaneyfelt would have reached a different conclusion if he had the same prints.

Tim,

I am not assuming anything. I am merely stating that Shaneyfelt declined to make a positive identification and in doing so his opinion is not the same as the panel's expert.

You can speculate all you like about what would and coud have been if Shaneyfelt had better photos but I prefer to stick with the facts.

[Tim Nickerson]

Tim,

I am not assuming anything. I am merely stating that Shaneyfelt declined to make a positive identification and in doing so his opinion is not the same as the panel's expert.

You can speculate all you like about what would and coud have been if Shaneyfelt had better photos but I prefer to stick with the facts.

Martin, Shaneyfelt and Kirk were not opining on the same thing. Shaneyfelt did not express an opinion on the quality prints that Kirk had at his disposal. Shaneyfelt and Kirk were not in disagreement.

[Wesley Johnson]

Wes, the authenticity of the backyard photos is not in doubt. They were authenticated by the HSCA's photographic analysis panel. Of which there were 22 members.

On edit, I see that you are already aware of that.

Yeah, I know Tim. It's just fun debating these guys on their crap they put out.

[Bill Brown]

What conspiracy do I claim? Pray tell....

Are the Dallas Police tapes authentic?

Only the part that the HSCA used to come up with their 95% probability of conspiracy finding.

Indeed.

[Wesley Johnson]

Pardon the pun, but that is a cop-out. You accept the DPD's UNSUPPORTED  claims so you are just as guilty of falsely accusing LHO.

I still see no evidence showing that LHO was guilty as you claim.

You are using the Mcadams term of "buff" a lot. To me a buff is someone who takes things in a laissez-faire way and either does NOT learn the evidence or makes accusations with NO supporting evidence. That would be you "Wes the buff".

Oh, you really told me Rob. I'm so impressed. You have zero evidence. Explain how the evidence gathered by the DPD is unsupported.

[John Iacoletti]

Neither Martin nor Colin has given an example, in all history, of a conspiracy to commit a murder, recruited the assassin and/or patsy, or multiple assassins and/or patsies and waited from one of them to luck into a job that gives them a good opportunity to murder the President, or to be framed for doing so.

What is it with you and the strawman arguments?  Did Martin or Colin ever claim that Oswald was recruited by anybody for any assassination-related purpose prior to getting a job at the TSBD?

[John Iacoletti]

A rifle?

Typical dishonest Mytton illustration.  Do you really think that this is a valid representation of what Marina would have seen peering into the end of a rolled up blanket that was tied with string?