JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion & Debate > JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion And Debate
How did Oswald get the job at the TSBD
Bill Brown:
--- Quote from: Martin Weidmann on March 12, 2018, 05:28:36 PM ---What conspiracy do I claim? Pray tell....
--- End quote ---
Are the Dallas Police tapes authentic?
Colin Crow:
--- Quote from: Bill Brown on March 12, 2018, 11:26:48 PM ---
So Lee Oswald assassinated President Kennedy from his workplace?
--- End quote ---
I am not sure Bill. He may have. I was using the official versions of both assassinations to hilight the fallacy of Joe's assumptions.
Certainly if you have anything more I am more than willing to be convinced. Then again conspiracy does not require Oswald not to be the shooter, does it?
Joe Elliott:
--- Quote from: Colin Crow on March 13, 2018, 12:48:40 AM ---
I am not sure Bill. He may have. I was using the official versions of both assassinations to hilight the fallacy of Joe's assumptions.
Certainly if you have anything more I am more than willing to be convinced. Then again conspiracy does not require Oswald not to be the shooter, does it?
--- End quote ---
There are no fallacies in my argument. Only yours.
Question:
Is the Booth assassination of Lincoln an example of a conspiracy where Booth was selected to take part, the other conspirators waited until Booth lucked into a job that gave him a good chance to assassinate the President and then assassinated the President?
Answer:
No.
Booth was an actor before he thought of kidnapping or killing Lincoln. Booth was an actor before Lincoln was elected President. There were thousands of men in the Washington D. C. area who hated Lincoln. Booth, unlike the other thousands, may have started to think about kidnapping or murdering Lincoln because he knew that Lincoln sometimes visited the place he had worked in, the Ford?s Theatre. Booth lucked into a job that allowed him a good chance to kill the President before there was a conspiracy.
Question:
Can you name a single instance, that a conspiracy chose a participant in an assassination, and waited for that participant to luck unto a job putting him in a good position to commit the murder? And then had him commit the murder or to serve as a patsy.
Don?t re-word the question to something like, ?Can you think of an example that a Lone Nut happened to work in the same place the President often visited, and decided to murder the President, and then recruited others, making it a conspiracy.? I need an example where the Conspiracy came first, then one of the participants lucked into a certain job. Not an example where someone lucked into a job and decided to form a conspiracy.
If your answer is, ?Yes, the Booth-Lincoln assassination? then you have failed to come up with an example. The formation of the conspiracy must occur before the fortunate job. Like CTers alleged happened with the Oswald-Kennedy assassination.
I am confident you cannot come up with a single example.
Tim Nickerson:
--- Quote from: Bill Brown on March 12, 2018, 11:53:10 PM ---Are the Dallas Police tapes authentic?
--- End quote ---
Only the part that the HSCA used to come up with their 95% probability of conspiracy finding. ;D
Wesley Johnson:
--- Quote from: Martin Weidmann on March 12, 2018, 09:53:56 PM ---just keep questioning every little piece of evidence.
Is it your position that evidence, no matter how small, should not be examined and questioned?
As for the photo it shows Oswald had a rifle and revolver.
I was once photographed with a rifle. Do you think that means I owned that rifle?
--- End quote ---
Read the quote again Martin. Since I have a feel for how you and others operate here I intentionally worded it "as for the photo it shows Oswald had a rifle and revolver" to see if you would say rifle"Do you think that means I owned that rifle ?"You didn't fail me Martin. Although I believe the rifle was linked to Ozzie quite well.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version