Youtube Interview I Did, Tippit Case

[Bill Chapman]

Weidmann should feel free to squint to his heart's content before he says 'how would you know how bad her eyesight was'

[Martin Weidmann]

You want some fries with that nothing-burger? 

And does your 'counter-narrative' include the comment about Earlene having only a couple of seconds to see if Oswald was wearing a jacket or not? It must be, since I've schooled you on this very point before, using a similar blurred, mocking image... and yet here you are repeating yourself.

And did you finally work out if the figure in my mocking-mockup (so-to-speak) is wearing a jacket or not?

Pathetic.

As you haven't got a clue on how blurred Roberts' vision really was, your blurred picture is meaningless.

There is a major difference between briefly seeing somebody walking behind you, needing only seconds to get from his room to the front door, while you try to get the television to work and a picture frame from a Gary Mack video which you can watch as long as you like.

But I'll play, just for fun. The video shows the man wearing a jacket, so there is no mystery there, but if this guy would walk passed you in a matter of two or three seconds, under the same circumstances as Roberts saw him, you could easily confuse the jacket for a vest, cardigan or sweater.

[Martin Weidmann]

Again, for the four millionth time...

Forget 162.  Got that now?

Forget Tenth and Patton.

Oswald left the rooming house zipping up a jacket as he went out the door.  Oswald is seen by Johnny Brewer on Jefferson with no jacket.  Why did Oswald ditch his jacket between the rooming house on Beckley and the shoe store on Jefferson?

There you go again, ignoring the evidence you don't like and assuming (1) that Oswald left the rooming house with a jacket and (2) that it was Oswald who ditched a jacket.

Only a fool asks the same question over and over again, expecting a different result.

[Martin Weidmann]

Except, it does.  She told a reporter almost immediately that Oswald left in a jacket.  She didn't tell anyone about the supposed horn-honking incident until a week later and by that time, the alleged assassin was himself gunned down, sparking rumors of a plot.


No.  Like it or not, there are grey areas.


Frazier is an obvious liar.  These days, I don't trust a single thing he said.

Except, it does.  She told a reporter almost immediately that Oswald left in a jacket.  She didn't tell anyone about the supposed horn-honking incident until a week later and by that time, the alleged assassin was himself gunned down, sparking rumors of a plot.

Wow! As I said before, she may well have believed that Oswald left in a jacket, but that doesn't automatically mean he did.
But it's very enlightening that you find a person credible despite the fact that you accuse her of making up a story after Oswald's death!

No.  Like it or not, there are grey areas.

Only when it is convenient for you

Frazier is an obvious liar.  These days, I don't trust a single thing he said.

And Roberts is exposed as a compulsive liar by her own employer. I don't believe a single thing she said. At least not without corroboration.

Frazier denied the TSBD bag as the one Oswald carried on day 1 and he hasn't changed his story one bit ever since.

[Bill Brown]

There you go again, ignoring the evidence you don't like and assuming (1) that Oswald left the rooming house with a jacket and (2) that it was Oswald who ditched a jacket.

Only a fool asks the same question over and over again, expecting a different result.

I'm hoping for a REASONABLE answer, eventually.  You're right, probably is foolish of me to expect one.

[Martin Weidmann]

I'm hoping for a REASONABLE answer, eventually.  You're right, probably is foolish of me to expect one.

"Reasonable" as in "one I like"?

Prove to me conclusively that Oswald left the roominghouse wearing a jacket and that he ditched it somewhere, and I'll give you a different answer. But don't ask me to play along with your assumptions! 

[Bill Brown]

"Reasonable" as in "one I like"?

Prove to me conclusively that Oswald left the roominghouse wearing a jacket and that he ditched it somewhere, and I'll give you a different answer. But don't ask me to play along with your assumptions!

So Oswald left the rooming house zipping up "a vest, cardigan or sweater"  Got it.

Sorry, but you fail my litmus test.  You aren't really interested in the truth; you just wanna play games.