CT's, in court how would you defend Oswald?

[John Mytton]

"There is no doubt" is LN-ese for "in my opinion".

No, the vast majority of the ear-witnesses said they heard 3 shots.

JohnM

[John Iacoletti]

No, the vast majority of the ear-witnesses said they heard 3 shots.

https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/bandwagon

[Bill Chapman]

Cite please.

Mr. JENNER - I am not thinking so much within the letter. Did she go beyond stating that he was merely only angry? Was there any discussion about his having struck her?
Mrs. PAINE - No; none. No; none. She never mentioned to me ever that Lee had struck her.
Mr. JENNER - And during all the visits you ever had with her, all the tete-a-tetes, her living with you on this occasion we now describe as 15 1/2 days, and in the fall, was there any occasion when Marina Oswald related to you any abuse, physical abuse, by her husband, Lee Harvey Oswald, with respect to her?
Mrs. PAINE - There was never any such occasion.

https://www.google.ca/amp/s/www.pressdemocrat.com/news/2884078-181/oswalds-wife-finds-a-cryptic%3fview=AMP

'By that time in the spring of 1963, Paine said, she'd come to resent that Oswald was physically abusive of Marina and he wanted to control and keep her isolated.'

[Martin Weidmann]

https://www.google.ca/amp/s/www.pressdemocrat.com/news/2884078-181/oswalds-wife-finds-a-cryptic%3fview=AMP

'By that time in the spring of 1963, Paine said, she'd come to resent that Oswald was physically abusive of Marina and he wanted to control and keep her isolated.'

Amazing….


In her testimony Paine says that Marina never mentioned to her that Lee had struck her and even after her return to Dallas in September 1963 Marina never mentioned any abuse by Lee.

 
So, how could Paine "come to resent that Oswald was physically abusive of Marina" when she had no way of knowing that?

[Colin Crow]

https://www.google.ca/amp/s/www.pressdemocrat.com/news/2884078-181/oswalds-wife-finds-a-cryptic%3fview=AMP

'By that time in the spring of 1963, Paine said, she'd come to resent that Oswald was physically abusive of Marina and he wanted to control and keep her isolated.'

But the testimony stands. Ruth resented Oswald's controlling Marina......indeed......who was controlling whom?

[John Mytton]

https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/bandwagon

Huh?

Your example is chalk and cheese, this isn't an "idea", these people were not imagining anything, they can only give evidence of what they heard.



JohnM

[Martin Weidmann]

Huh?

Your example is chalk and cheese, this isn't an "idea", these people were not imagining anything, they can only give evidence of what they heard.



JohnM

Are you pleading ignorance or do you truly not understand John's valid point?

[John Mytton]

Are you pleading ignorance or do you truly not understand John's valid point?

Did you read the page that was linked to, they were discussing "ideas" that haven't been experienced, like "Flat Earth" or "Leprechauns" whereas these people actually heard the evidence that we are discussing, what's the connection?

As usual I provide the evidence and you call them liars, when will it ever end?



JohnM