Gen. Walker and Supreme Court Decision

[John Iacoletti]

You're simply being a contrarian and perverse..... We both know that the police grabbed a carload of Lee's possessions and hauled it to the police station that afternoon. 

So you have no answer for how you know they were Oswald’s possessions then.

The photo that the DPD took shows the controversial photo lying on the blue note book that was the false dossier that Lee had created. 

Your “false dossier” fabrication and your “Walker hoax” fabrication are no more compelling than the stories the LNers come up with.

[Tom Scully]

So you have no answer for how you know they were Oswald’s possessions then.

Your “false dossier” fabrication and your “Walker hoax” fabrication are no more compelling than the stories the LNers come up with.

John, I brought this thread back to the first page because I found "this guy," two days ago....



John, what are you and Walt debating about? Why not just agree this is all hinky, and call it a day, for now?
Please interrupt, if you object to any of the following points.

The young man above was on the Minuteman membership list in 1963, he was a "very conservative republican," wanting to "abolish the Supreme Court," and had a mocking opinion of FDR intense enough to be displayed, along with his political party affiliation and his opinion of SCOTUS, in his high school yearbook profile.

Just after graduating high school in 1963 in St. Paul, MN, he flies to Dallas, meets with Edwin Walker, films Walker's mailbox to I.D. it in the very short 8mm color film he was taking, and, on August 9, on the same reel, films LHO and his leaflets in NOLA. In December, he offers the film to the FBI.

DPD served up this photo, allegedly found in Oswald's seized belongings.:


Six years later, in his book, then retired DPD Chief Curry serves up this version.:

[Walt Cakebread]

John, I brought this thread back to the first page because I found "this guy," two days ago....



John, what are you and Walt debating about? Why not just agree this is all hinky, and call it a day, for now?
Please interrupt, if you object to any of the following points.

The young man above was on the Minuteman membership list in 1963, he was a "very conservative republican," wanting to "abolish the Supreme Court," and had a mocking opinion of FDR intense enough to be displayed, along with his political party affiliation and his opinion of SCOTUS, in his high school yearbook profile.

Just after graduating high school in 1963 in St. Paul, MN, he flies to Dallas, meets with Edwin Walker, films Walker's mailbox to I.D. it in the very short 8mm color film he was taking, and, on August 9, on the same reel, films LHO and his leaflets in NOLA. In December, he offers the film to the FBI.

DPD served up this photo, allegedly found in Oswald's seized belongings.:


Six years later, in his book, then retired DPD Chief Curry serves up this version.:

These two photos may have been made from the same negative ...but they are NOT the same print.    Clearly the print that was published on page 113 of Curry's book has not had the license plate obliterated and it is not damaged .....  But I fail to understand how it's possible for any rational person to deny that Lee had an undamaged (Walker house) photo among his possessions on 11/22/63.

DPD served up this photo, allegedly found in Oswald's seized belongings.:


Six years later, in his book, then retired DPD Chief Curry serves up this version.:

[Jerry Freeman]

Clearly the print that was published on page 113 of Curry's book has not had the license plate obliterated and it is not damaged ..... 

Someone did not want that vehicle traced. Is that not suspicious in itself?

[Walt Cakebread]

Someone did not want that vehicle traced. Is that not suspicious in itself?

Yes, Jerry it's obvious that someone in authority with the police or FBI did NOT want the owner of that 1957 Chevy identified.

I know that you don't believe Marina ( Which is unfortunate) but Marina was emphatic that the license plate was intact when the FBI presented the photo to her in early December.(on Dec 2nd ?)and asked her if she knew whose house was pictured in the photo.....And she told them she thought that it was General Walker's house.

[Jerry Freeman]

  Marina was emphatic that the license plate was intact when the FBI presented the photo to her in early December....

I can believe that.

... asked her if she knew whose house was pictured in the photo.....And she told them she thought that it was General Walker's house.

Well...someone told her this.

[Walt Cakebread]

I can believe that. Well...someone told her this.

someone told her this.

Yes ....You're right.  It's very doubtful that Marina would have guessed that it was Walker's house in the photo.   Lee told her that it was Walker's house.

At the time the FBI started questioning her about the contents of the blue notebook ( the false dossier) they knew very little about Lee's involvement in the Walker Hoax.  They had learned the the story in the German newspaper had originated with Walker when Walker called his friend, who was the editor of the paper,  in Germany on Saturday morning 11/23/63 and told that editor that Lee Oswald was the man who had tried to kill him in April of 1963.