Where Were Jane Berry, Betty Thornton and Peggy Burney During the Motorcade?

[John Iacoletti]

Yeah, "Pillbox" was there. 

Yeah, giving witnesses cute little nicknames really convinces anyone that your opinion is correct.

 

[Thomas Graves]

Yeah, giving witnesses cute little nicknames really convinces anyone that your opinion is correct.

 

Iacoletti,

Westbrook's "identification" of herself and her good bud, Gloria Calvert (sic) in the Z-film (from behind and 54 years after-the-fact) was so far off that "Pillbox" may very well be a very apt "play" on her married name, don't you think?

Btw, which theory do you prefer today -- 1) that Carol Reed (or Karan Hicks) had black hair and an American Indian-like dark complexion, or 2) that black-haired and dark-complected Stella Mae Jacob bailed on her two Texas School Book Company colleagues (Gloria Holt and Sharon Simmons) in order to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with South-Western Publishing Company colleagues Gloria Calvery and Karen Westbrook, while two of their colleagues (Reed and Hicks) bailed on them?

--  MWT   

PS  If #1, above, then where-oh-where is Karan Hicks?

PPS  Oops, my bad.  I confused Westbrook with Mary Woodward Pillsworth (someone who, when interviewed by Stephen "Smilin' 'n Noddin'" Fagin, did have an excellent memory, btw).

Hmm.

Can I change her nickname to "Can't Tell" Scranton?

EDIT:  But you know something?

I kinda like "Pillbox" for her.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pillbox_(military)

[John Iacoletti]

Westbrook's "identification" of herself and her good bud, Gloria Calvert (sic) in the Z-film (from behind and 54 years after-the-fact) was so far off that "Pillbox" may very well be a very apt "play" on her married name, don't you think?

Merely calling a witness wrong (particularly about who she herself is) is not a particularly compelling argument that your opinion is correct.

[Thomas Graves]

Merely calling a witness wrong (particularly about who she herself is) is not a particularly compelling argument that your opinion is correct.

Iacoletti,

You just don't get it.

Despite your apparent wishes otherwise, Westbrook was wrong.

Too bad she couldn't remember she was standing three people to the left of her good friend and colleague Gloria Calvert [sic], and that she wore her dress to the motorcade, not her raincoat, and that her headscarf was very light blue, not medium blue, and that Calvert's [sic] hair was much redder than strawberry-blond Holt's, and that Calvert [sic] was so ... large.

The assassination must have been very traumatic for Westbrook to have messed up her memory so much.

But then again, it was 54 years earlier, and from behind ...

-- MWT 

[John Iacoletti]

Iacoletti,

You just don't get it.

Despite your apparent wishes otherwise, Westbrook was wrong.

Merely calling a witness wrong (particularly about who she herself is) is not a particularly compelling argument that your opinion is correct.

[Thomas Graves]

Iacoletti,

Cute!

Did they teach you how to do that in your software debugging class?


Since you refuse to answer my earlier questions, let me rephrase them into just one for you.

Which of these seven gals, if any, lied (or were mysteriously mistaken) in their FBI statements as to who they watched the motorcade with?

1) Stella Mae Jacob of Texas School Book Company

2) Gloria Holt of Texas School Book Company

3) Sharon Simmons of Texas School Book Company


4) Karen Westbrook of South-Western Publishing Company

5) Carol Reed of South-Western Publishing Company

6) Karan Hicks of South-Western Publishing Company

7) Gloria Calvery of South-Western Publishing Company

 
For Karen Westbrook Scranton's memory to be correct, the answer is "everybody, myself included".
https://www.history-matters.com/archive/jfk/wc/wcvols/wh22/pdf/WH22_CE_1381.pdf


--  MWT 

[John Iacoletti]

Here's where Tommy just declares that "with" must mean standing side-by-side for the entire duration of the motorcade and even several minutes afterwards.

Because.....well, because he said so.

[Thomas Graves]

Here's where Tommy just declares that "with" must mean standing side-by-side for the entire duration of the motorcade and even several minutes afterwards.

What you're really saying is that all seven of those gals played fast-and-loose, syntactically speaking, with the FBI in their signed statements.

Your insinuating that only serves to highlight the ludicrousness of your "position" on Calvery.

You must be really desperate to "prevent" Gloria Calvery's getting to the TSBD steps within 25 seconds after the final shot, as depicted in Darnell.

Why is that, John?

Are you afraid that that would somehow implicate Oswald in the assassination of JFK?

--  MWT 

PS  Have you actually read Karen Westbrook's FBI statement?