Recent Posts

Recent Posts

Pages: 1 ... 8 9 [10]
91
I’m going to keep an open mind about it until I can prove beyond doubt that it is as ludicrous as it appears to be or until Andrew proves it via
rigorous demonstration that 3/4ths of LNs agree with. 😬
A reasonable unbiased person looking objectively at the evidence realizes that the evidence against Oswald is very strong. It is really overwhelming.  There is also strong evidence that three shots were fired from the SN.  Several witnesses saw the rifle in the SN and three men on the floor below heard the three shots from above them. So it is easy to conclude from the evidence that Oswald was the sole assassin.

The problem is trying to reconcile the Zfilm with three shots from a bolt action rifle. Without the Zfilm there would likely not have been a need to invent the SBT.

LNs have been persuaded that Connally was reacting to being shot in the torso by z230.  I don’t know why that is.

When I first studied the issue I read the evidence of Connally and tried to match his evidence to the zfilm.  I had no difficulty seeing that, according to Connally’s evidence, JBC was reacting to the first shot at z230 by turning around just as he said he did after hearing the shot and realizing that an assassination was unfolding.  Further reading of the evidence of witnesses who described the shot spacing made it abundantly clear that there was only one shot by z230; that the second shot which was closer to z313 than to the first.  Then the zfilm started to make sense.

So after the midpoint between the first and last shots is where the evidence says to look for an indication of the second shot hitting JBC in the torso. The motion of JBC beginning at about z271-272 and immediately falling back as Greer turns around fits the evidence perfectly. The hair on the right side of JFK’s head flying up at z273 fits what George Hickey saw at the time he heard the second shot. There are several other indications all pointing to JBC being hit in those frames.

But it is hard to see if you are not willing to even consider it.
92
If one is foolish enough to consult AI - which I am not, but my bmboficated research assistant Cuddles LaFong is  ::) - it appears that my guess of a disociative state may be in the ballpark. AI says "Yes, violent criminals are sometimes extremely calm after committing their acts. While public perception often assumes a perpetrator would be frantic, panicked, or guilt-ridden, forensic psychologists, criminologists, and law enforcement officers frequently document intense post-crime composure." AI says lots more, but I will spare you. I suppose that after deciding the JFKA was what he was going to do and that he would probably die in the aftermath, Oswald could have been in something like a disociative state even during his visit to Irving.
93
Is there a CT'er who has a better answer than “He was completely innocent and really had no idea what was going on?”--Lp

Yes, LHO was part of a quickly formed, low-budget conspiracy, around the (bad) luck that the JFK motorcade (revealed publicly on Nov. 19) would make a hairpin turn right in front the TSBD, with its largely empty upper floors, and clear view to a kill.

A perfect set-up. The best place in Dallas to perp the JFKA, and LHO already "had an in."

LHO had a proclivity for shooting at major public figures---see the Walker shooting. He needed convincing?

In fact, LHO had worked out a reasonable escape plan from the immediate TSBD premises, and did escape from there. So good enough on that score.

As for longer-term LHO plans, everything is speculation. In my layman's view, LHO was mentally ill.

Perhaps G-2 had promised LHO passage to Cuba, but actually planned to wax LHO.

LHO was "left holding the bag." Maybe. LHO planned to write his manifesto in Cuba?

A post JFKA-ride was promised to LHO, but fell through---possibly.

The 1,800-mile border to Mexico was wide-open back then, and boats left for Cuba from Mexico daily.

Who knows?

All he had to do was wipe his Carcano down with his already-off shirt, hide it (the Carcano), put his shirt back on while going down the stairs, and get to the second-floor lunch room before anyone saw him -- maybe even with a pre-purchased bottle of Coke-Cola (Larry Hancock's expression) to use as a prop.

Regarding Fancy Pants Rants assertion that he couldn't have PERPED ("BC's" expression) the JFKA because he gave his taxicab to a woman, should he have kept it for himself and appeared to be in a big rush?
94
Is there a CT'er who has a better answer than “He was completely innocent and really had no idea what was going on?”--Lp

Yes, LHO was part of a quickly formed, low-budget conspiracy, around the (bad) luck that the JFK motorcade (revealed publicly on Nov. 19) would make a hairpin turn right in front the TSBD, with its largely empty upper floors, and clear view to a kill.

A perfect set-up. The best place in Dallas to perp the JFKA, and LHO already "had an in."

LHO had a proclivity for shooting at major public figures---see the Walker shooting. He needed convincing?

In fact, LHO had worked out a reasonable escape plan from the immediate TSBD premises, and did escape from there. So good enough on that score.

As for longer-term LHO plans, everything is speculation. In my layman's view, LHO was mentally ill.

Perhaps G-2 had promised LHO passage to Cuba, but actually planned to wax LHO.

LHO was "left holding the bag." Maybe. LHO planned to write his manifesto in Cuba?

A post JFKA-ride was promised to LHO, but fell through---possibly.

The 1,800-mile border to Mexico was wide-open back then, and boats left for Cuba from Mexico daily.

Who knows?

You are pointedly ignoring the subject of this thread. I'm not looking for conspiracy theories. I can weave those all day long. I'm looking for how Oswald's seemingly out-of-character preternatural composure before and after the JFKA is explained in the context of a conspiracy theory (or the LN narrative, for that matter).
95
To argue against myself - "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds," as Ralph Waldo Emerson said - the two obvious outliers are the murder of Tippit and the supposed incident in the Texas Theater. This was not the preternaturally calm and collected Oswald. I have considerable doubt that the TT incident took place as the arresting officers described - it just doesn't make sense - but the murder of Tippit is a huge outlier. This seems more like the real Oswald. Perhaps he was backed into a corner, figuratively speaking, and felt he had no choice. All very weird.
96
Is there a CT'er who has a better answer than “He was completely innocent and really had no idea what was going on?”--Lp

Yes, LHO was part of a quickly formed, low-budget conspiracy, around the (bad) luck that the JFK motorcade (revealed publicly on Nov. 19) would make a hairpin turn right in front the TSBD, with its largely empty upper floors, and clear view to a kill.

A perfect set-up. The best place in Dallas to perp the JFKA, and LHO already "had an in."

LHO had a proclivity for shooting at major public figures---see the Walker shooting. He needed convincing?

In fact, LHO had worked out a reasonable escape plan from the immediate TSBD premises, and did escape from there. So good enough on that score.

As for longer-term LHO plans, everything is speculation. In my layman's view, LHO was mentally ill.

Perhaps G-2 had promised LHO passage to Cuba, but actually planned to wax LHO.

LHO was "left holding the bag." Maybe. LHO planned to write his manifesto in Cuba?

A post JFKA-ride was promised to LHO, but fell through---possibly.

The 1,800-mile border to Mexico was wide-open back then, and boats left for Cuba from Mexico daily.

Who knows?



97
Blissfully, TG is so far in my rearview mirror that I actually don't remember even starting this thread.

I've really, really missed you, Fancy Pants Rancid!
98
Blissfully, TG is so far in my rearview mirror that I actually don't remember even starting this thread.

So many JFKA rabbit holes, so little time.
99
Dear Mr. Thomas Graves,

Have you never read The Pumpkin Papers sir?
Nyet? OMG!@you if you have not.
Then get back to me about "Mr. Bagley" after you're through.

What would you like to know about them?
100
To be clear, I'm not talking about Oswald's motive. I can articulate a plausible motive and have done so. As John Corbett suggests, it is a mixed motive. A life and marriage that was going nowhere, an exalted view of himself, his genuine pro-Castro sympathies, and Fate seemingly handing him a golden opportunity.

I'm talking about his behavior, which is quite astonishing for a guy who has just shot the POTUS and presumably knows there is a mountain of evidence against him. His preternatural composure in the encounter with Baker and Truly ... offering Whaley's cab to a stranger … yada yada as set forth in my original post - this is someone who has just shot the President? And again, contrast his behavior here with the Walker shooting - a detailed note for Marina and still agitated when he gets home.

Steve makes an interesting point, but wait: By the time Oswald bums the ride from Frazier and visits the Paine home, he has clearly formulated the JFKA - presumably the night before. Yet he shows none of the stress Marina had previously witnessed - nada, zilch. Ditto for the ride back to the TSBD with Frazier and his morning in the TSBD. (His weird question to Jarman as though he doesn't know JFK's motorcade will be passing in front of the TSBD - what was that all about?) Ditto for his post-arrest behavior. This is all part-and-parcel of the seemingly preternatural composure I'm talking about. How does he pull this off?

I really don’t have a good answer. He seems to know something that is outside the scope of the LN narrative, but I can’t put my finger on it. It’s as though he’s somehow been “programmed” to stay calm and admit absolutely nothing - whatever "programmed" may mean in this context. This is a different Oswald than we would have expected under the circumstances – indeed, different from what almost anyone would be like under the circumstances. Is he in some disociative state, perhaps?

Is there a CTer who has a better answer than “He was completely innocent and really had no idea what was going on?”
Pages: 1 ... 8 9 [10]