JFK Assassination Forum

And how do you know for a fact that Roberts, who was paying more attention to the television and had bad vision, was absolutely right?

I can't remember a single time over the past 35 years that I cited Earlene Roberts statements to support any argument I've made.

The discussion is about consistent. Start from the ground up. What did she say? Interesting you would gravitate to her estimation of the length as if that was all defining.

I don't play games. You know exactly what she said.
Make your point  you wanna add that left hand again?

You're on your own.

If one witness can be wrong, two can be wrong. There is also the very reel possibility that Frazier and his sister discussed the bag between themselves which could have influenced their recollections.

The simple reality is neither of the two had any reason to estimate the length of the package at the time they observed it. They were only asked to estimate the length of the package from memory some time later.

Estimates are likely never precise, but do you agree that estimating the size is not the same as observing how the package was carried by Oswald?

If one witness can be wrong, two can be wrong. There is also the very reel possibility that Frazier and his sister discussed the bag between themselves which could have influenced their recollections.

The simple reality is neither of the two had any reason to estimate the length of the package at the time they observed it. They were only asked to estimate the length of the package from memory some time later.

Yet, Here is a picture of Frazier demonstrating to you exactly what he saw and even should have seen...
You are just not being honest.

What about Linnie Mae Randle or doesn't her statement and testimony count?

If one witness can be wrong, two can be wrong. There is also the very reel possibility that Frazier and his sister discussed the bag between themselves which could have influenced their recollections.

The simple reality is neither of the two had any reason to estimate the length of the package at the time they observed it. They were only asked to estimate the length of the package from memory some time later.