JFK Assassination Forum

If one witness can be wrong, two can be wrong. There is also the very reel possibility that Frazier and his sister discussed the bag between themselves which could have influenced their recollections.

The simple reality is neither of the two had any reason to estimate the length of the package at the time they observed it. They were only asked to estimate the length of the package from memory some time later.

If one witness can be wrong, two can be wrong. There is also the very reel possibility that Frazier and his sister discussed the bag between themselves which could have influenced their recollections.

The simple reality is neither of the two had any reason to estimate the length of the package at the time they observed it. They were only asked to estimate the length of the package from memory some time later.

What about Linnie Mae Randle or doesn't her statement and testimony count?

Here's Frazier on 11/22 and for the next 60+ years:
"I noticed that Lee had the package in his right hand under his arm, and the package was straight up and down, and he had his arm down, and you could not see much of the package."   https://jfk-online.com/frazier.html

He doesn't need to be a "super witness" to know exactly what he saw and it is not every detail.
It is very specific and consistent. You're the one that continues to deny that.

You are reading more into his statement that is there. Carrying the package under his arm does not preclude the top end sticking up above his shoulder.