Recent Posts

Recent Posts

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 ... 10
31
JC-

I conclude LHO has confederates based upon my observation Gov. JBC was shot at ~Z-295.

No wonder you reached a FUBAR conclusion. You started with a FUBAR premise.
Quote

Connally: I was knocked over, just doubled over by the force of the bullet. It went in my back and came out my chest about 2 inches below and the left of my right nipple. The force of the bullet drove my body over almost double and when I looked, immediately I could see I was just drenched with blood. (1 HSCA 42)

That happens ~Z-295.

WRONG!!! It started over 3 seconds earlier.
Quote

I have reasonable doubts JBC was shot through the chest ~Z-223, but after that executed a 180-degree turn in his seat to check on JFK.

Keep the silliness coming. We've had over 62 years of it. We can take a bit more.
Quote

In addition, I have reasonable doubts JBC was shot through the wrist at Z-223 by a large slug, that "tumbled" (WC version) through his wrist, shattered bone, but that JBC is seen gripping his Stetson at Z-275 without apparent injury. Huh? This does not hold water.

Why would you expect him to let go of his Stetson?
Quote

Thereafter, after tumbling through JBC's wrist, then CE-399 untumbled and made a small round hole entering JBC's pant leg, and burrowed into his leg. The WC version. Really?

OK, so the slug was removed from JBC in surgery (says JBC) but then ends up on the floor by elevators away from the surgery room. This despite well-known hospital regulations that all bullet wounds are reported to police and evidence retained. Hospital employee Tomlinson finds the CE-399 slug inexplicably lying on the floor, and gives it to OP Wright, hospital administrator and former police chief.

The bullet was turned over to the Secret Service.
Quote

Wright says the Parkland Hospital slug had a pointy head, like most 30.06 slugs. A former cop said that.

Here we go again. Relying on fallible eyewitness recollections instead of the bullet that was turned over to the Secret Service and positively identified by the FBI to have been fired by Oswald's rifle to the exclusion of all other weapons in the world. CE399 was the only bullet found at Parkland.
Quote

The WC had a mandate:

Repeating the same lie over and over again doesn't make it more credible. It just makes you look foolish. But you should be used to that by now.
Quote

Determine an LN leftie-loser-loner Marxist acted alone. LBJ told Richard Russell, and Earl Warren, he wanted no results that might trigger a nuke war. Reasonable enough concern.

Either you made that up or you are repeating something somebody else made up.
Quote


Did LBJ suspect the Mafia, US-based right-wingers or US-intel types? Mossad?

Obviously not. He suspected G2 or KGB. He had good reasons.

It's amazing the things you have convinced yourself of that aren't supported by a single piece of credible evidence. Only imagination and speculation.
32
JC-

I conclude LHO has confederates based upon my observation Gov. JBC was shot at ~Z-295.

Connally: I was knocked over, just doubled over by the force of the bullet. It went in my back and came out my chest about 2 inches below and the left of my right nipple. The force of the bullet drove my body over almost double and when I looked, immediately I could see I was just drenched with blood. (1 HSCA 42)

That happens ~Z-295.

I have reasonable doubts JBC was shot through the chest ~Z-223, but after that executed a 180-degree turn in his seat to check on JFK.

In addition, I have reasonable doubts JBC was shot through the wrist at Z-223 by a large slug, that "tumbled" (WC version) through his wrist, shattered bone, but that JBC is seen gripping his Stetson at Z-275 without apparent injury. Huh? This does not hold water.

Thereafter, after tumbling through JBC's wrist, then CE-399 untumbled and made a small round hole entering JBC's pant leg, and burrowed into his leg. The WC version. Really?

OK, so the slug was removed from JBC in surgery (says JBC) but then ends up on the floor by elevators away from the surgery room. This despite well-known hospital regulations that all bullet wounds are reported to police and evidence retained. Hospital employee Tomlinson finds the CE-399 slug inexplicably lying on the floor, and gives it to OP Wright, hospital administrator and former police chief.

Wright says the Parkland Hospital slug had a pointy head, like most 30.06 slugs. A former cop said that.

The WC had a mandate: Determine an LN leftie-loser-loner Marxist acted alone. LBJ told Richard Russell, and Earl Warren, he wanted no results that might trigger a nuke war. Reasonable enough concern.

Did LBJ suspect the Mafia, US-based right-wingers or US-intel types? Mossad?

Obviously not. He suspected G2 or KGB. He had good reasons.
33
Agreed.  I'm just saying there was no actual time that Oswald was supposed to be transferred; only that it was going to be after 10 AM.

Had Ruby not needed to wire money via Western Union to one of his dancers, he probably would have seen Oswald peacefully transferred on TV from his apartment.
34
Anyone planning to kill Oswald would take that to mean he needed to be in the garage by 10 AM if he wanted to kill Oswald. Otherwise, he could miss his chance, Oswald would have been transferred to the county jail, stood trial, been convicted, sentenced to death, been spared by SCOTUS in 1972 and he might still be doing time in the Texas state penitentiary.

Quote
Anyone planning to kill Oswald would take that to mean he needed to be in the garage by 10 AM if he wanted to kill Oswald

Agreed.  I'm just saying there was no actual time that Oswald was supposed to be transferred; only that it was going to be after 10 AM.
35

  My fault. SA Hill.
36


37
Progress Zeon!  All very reasonable points.

You are beginning to realize that there is no way the evidence can fit a first shot miss.  However, I would not agree that JFK's reaction is delayed. It is rather difficult to accept that JFK is not reacting between z193 and before z224:



Neither JFK nor JBC had a delayed reaction. They both reacted at the same time to being hit by the same shot.
Quote

JBC's reaction was not to being hit by it in the back/armpit. So his reaction will be delayed because he has to process the significance of the sound, realize that the President may have been hit by a rifle shot and begin to turn around to catch sight of the President.

Total BS. It's not even good BS.[uote]

Dan's first shot SBT scenario might be more persuasive if there was a reasonable explanation for JBC being absolutely sure that he was not hit in the back/armpit by the first shot - and if there was cogent evidence of a third shot miss. Also, the shot had to be a bit earlier than z224. 

 

A second shot SBT perfectly fits with the Z-film and the medical evidence. JBC was directly in line with the bullet exiting JFK's throat. It simply could not have missed him. Your goofy drawings do not change that simple fact.
38
I didn't avoid the image evidence. I told you that I could see the pareidolic "face" at 29:30. Alas for you, neither I nor pretty much anyone else who has looked at this pareidolic face thinks it looks like our beloved Lamb Chop. Actually, at first blush I thought the image posted by Jack White looked more like Lamb Chop than your pareidolic flower face, It took me about 30 seconds to realize "Wait a minute, that's the purse of a woman on the sidewalk."

Bugiloisi (BOO! HISS!) says the following in his endnotes in Reclaiming History (BOO! HISS!):

Jean Hill took a lot of ribbing for telling reporters in a national TV interview shortly after the shooting that President and Mrs. Kennedy were looking at a little white dog on the seat between them as the car came abreast of Hill’s position. In later years, conspiracy theorists tried to restore her credibility by claiming that photographs taken at Love Field show that Mrs. Kennedy had been given a white, stuffed-toy version of the famous Sheri Lewis TV puppet, Lamb Chop. The claim, however, was based on poor-quality images posted on the Internet. High-quality images show that what critics thought was a Lamb Chop toy was, in fact, a bouquet of white asters. (Trask, That Day in Dallas , p.29).

I don't have the Trask book, but if you can find it take a look at page 29 and see if it clears up this non-mystery for you.

  Thanks for posting that page 29 photo.  I think that SA Greer carried a gun. I can Not see SA Greer's gun on your page 29 photo. Do you think that SA Greer had his gun on him? The page 29 photo has nothing to do with the 29:30 Lamb Chop Image.
  You guys continue wanting to direct this discussion toward anything but the actual 29:30 Lamb Chop Image. All I continually get is: (1) Where did this Lamb Chop come from?, (2) How did this Lamb Chop get inside the JFK Limo? and, (3) "run out the clock" endless Dodging. Just tell this Forum what YOU SEE at 29:30.  Or, if you believe this 29:30 Lamb Chop Image is a "planted/altered image", just put on your Big Boy Pants and say so. I do Not see the Lamb Chop Image as being "PAREIDOLIA". I do believe that legitimately can be argued with respect to "Badge Man". That I know of, this Lamb Chop Image has not been played with. The Badge Man Image required Hokey Pokey to produce that image. That is not necessary to see the 29:30 Lamb Chop Image.
39
Some - Robert Morrow - are, some aren't. Wackiness is in the eye of the beholder, but Robert is wacky by any standard.

Any theory of the assassination that is based on speculation and not hard evidence is wacky.
Quote

In my opinion the WC was tasked with toeing the LN line and fulfilled its mission.
Your opinion is a poor substitute for actual evidence that anybody but Oswald took part in the assassination.
Quote

There was a definite mandate and agenda not to reach a conclusion pointing to the obvious suspects given Oswald's background: the Soviets and/or Cubans.

Still waiting for your evidence that supports that claim.
Quote

A cui bono analysis would have included all those you listed (and more) precisely because so many individuals and organizations despised JFK and stood to benefit from his death.

Every POTUS has enemies. That doesn't mean they resort to assassination. The only person implicated by evidence is LHO. Everything else is unfounded speculation.
Quote


Indeed, it's quite an astonishing list. The WC legitimately started with Oswald since the Dealey Plaza evidence obviously pointed to him, yet the WC could articulate no clear motive.

It is completely unnecessary to establish Oswald's motive given the overwhelming amount of evidence he did the deed. Why he did it will never be known nor does it need to be known.
Quote


The WC then did some level of cursory analysis concerning Oswald's possible connections to conspirators and found none.


Why does that matter?
Quote

Generations of researchers have been dissatisfied with the WC's and HSCA's analyses and continued the quest.

Satisfying the CTs is completely unnecessary to establish that Oswald was the assassin.
Quote

Cui bono points so strongly to LBJ and Marcello that it sometimes seems almost impossible they weren't involved.

A completely illogical conclusion completely devoid of supporting evidence.
Quote


But the cui bono inquiry simply says "Yes, they had a hell of a motive and should be looked at closely." The WC certainly didn't do this, so I have no problem with CT researchers digging more deeply.

They've been digging for 62 years and have come up empty. They have found no evidence that indicates anybody but LHO was involved in the assassination. Suspicions without evidence doesn't amount to squat.
Quote

As to what they have produced so far, I would say there is no credible or compelling evidence.


BINGO!!!
Quote

But this is very common in routine criminal cases as well; the cui bono inquiry may lead nowhere and the perpetrator who is finally arrested turns out never to have been on anyone's radar screen until he slipped up. That was my only point with LBJ: cui bono would say "Take a hard, close look at this guy."

62 years of batting .000 gives us no reason to believe Oswald had any accomplices.
40
LP--

THERE WAS NO REASON TO HAVE A GUNMAN IN TSBD6 IN THE FIRST PLACE. (All caps in original). ---LP

Huh?

Of course, there was a reason to have a sniper in TSBD6---by luck, that was where LHO worked and had an excellent view to the motorcade. LHO could secret weapons into the TSBD with little chance of detection. LHO could be in the building with no questions, and on any floor. All that was a relatively low-risk op.

LHO could know when to allow others into the building with little chance of detection, and know how to leave the building quickly. LHO would know which floors were occupied, and which were not. Reducing risk.

By luck, TSBD6 was as good a JFKA set-up as could be found, on relatively short notice.

You are setting up arguments against a straw man CT---that a powerful high-level cabal perped the JFKA, and why would they use LHO?

But how about a JFKA perped by a couple low-level G2'ers, acting without authorization, but in touch with LHO, through LHO's activities in MC and NO? And an LHO had a proclivity for shooting at public figures---see the Walker shooting. 

The JFKAC was not sophisticated, and it was risky. So what?

A couple G2'ers did not have a lot of resources at their command, but got lucky with LHO.

For the G2'ers, the mission had to be accomplished, so risks were taken. That happens in the political-nationalist zealotry of the Cold War Latin America.

LHO? I do not pretend to understand LHO, he was likely mentally ill, and possibly thought he would end up in Cuba.

My guess is that LHO was left holding the bag, whether by design or circumstance, I don't know. Perhaps LHO was supposed to be waxed also, but in such a low-budget op as the JFKA, things can go wrong. 

The GK diversion was a success.

I am talked out.

Your beliefs lack two important elements. Oswald had no need for help from anybody. Killing JFK was a one man job.

The other thing you lack is evidence Oswald had any help. Your suggestion he had accomplices is based entirely on speculation.
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 ... 10