Recent Posts

Recent Posts

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 10
21
Hey, could you find a Gumby doll and figure out how Govnr Connally was sitting on the jump seat and which way his legs were positioned and how he was likely holding his hat during the Z film sequence and try out Andrew’s twisted pretzel position for JC at Z270?

I'd say that last picture is a fairly accurate representation of JFK's position in the limo. Assuming the side of the car is to scale, it does give a fairly good representation of JFK when he was shot in the back.

If you have another doll, I would just cut off the lower legs to allow it to fit and turn JBC's shoulders about where you think he was at Z222. You don't need the lower legs for this exercise.
22
All of those would be wonderful, but would they realistically be EXPECTED in a tight, compartmentalized Mafia hit of the POTUS - a hit that could literally destroy the organization if it went awry? Have a little respect for professionalism of the Mafia, willya? The American and Sicilian Mafia are estimated to have carried out thousands of successful hits over the past century. My expectation for the JFKA would be no more evidence than we have.

Alas, all of the Mafia-did-it books are not available on Kindle, so I'm going to have to load up on hard copies.

I know Larry Schnapf and Pat Speer lean toward the Mafia. I did a search on the Ed Forum and found what I expected: The Mafia gets little attention, and then only in the context of being a bit player in the elaborate and completely unbelievable LBJ, CIA and Everyone Else In the World Except Jackie and Hickey Conspiracy. The CT community simply cannot abide a conspiracy as dull and unsatisfying as the Mafia - just the Mafia.

There is as much evidence of Mafia involvement as there is for any other entity other than Oswald which is to say there is zero evidence. If you want to hypothesize a conspiracy for which you can find no evidence, that's your privilege. I choose to base my beliefs on real evidence.
23
Well I would suggest that if Oswald was the shooter and he was  part of a conspiracy, there were no plans for Oswald to be the patsy because surely there would have been a conspirator cameraman on the ground filming or getting a zoomed in photo of Oswald’s face as he stuck the rifle out the window.

Perhaps, but now we have a cameraman who is part of the conspiracy and is going to have to survive scrutiny of himself. I ran this past Phoebe Marcello, Carlos' cousin quadruply removed, and she said "Nah, I think they had Oswald sufficiently framed that photos would have been overkill. 'Overkill' - get it? Hee, hee, hee."

Quote
So if it’s a conspiracy, then Oswald was not the shooter although he might have been used by the conspirators after they found out he was kind if a kook who had taken pictures of himself with a rifle and revolver.

I will agree that Oswald being a shooter in a Mafia conspiracy that he thinks is a pro-Castro conspiracy bumps up against some of the problems I suggested with the LN narrative - he simply doesn't act like there is anything of that sort on his mind while he's in Irving or on the morning of the JFKA. On the other hand, to be the perfect Mafia patsy, he has to be a shooter who knows nothing except that he's in a pro-Castro conspiracy. In this scenario, it doesn't matter if he lives or dies. As I understand Orr's theory, Marcello recruits Oswald through the Dutz Murret connection and makes him an offer he can't refuse - but then Oswald knows too much and can't be allowed to live. I absolutely refuse to believe the Mafia would entrust the future of the entire organization to ... JACK RUBY?

Quote
That’s my Centrist perspective
 
Now who would know about Oswald’s rifle and his photos and that he had shot at Walker and all kinds of things helpful to the WC narrative ?That  would be Marina, the innocent naive  USSR girl who had coincidentally met all the other CIA defectors and of course said nothing at all to her relative KGB officer.

But we are not allowed to question poor little Marina , the one who in one WC testimony can barely speak English or understand it and then in other WC testimony is speaking English fluently and in great detail without a stumble. It’s a Miracle! Certainly the new husband is happy. However , George DeCIA spy , best friend of Oswald is depressed and finally reaches out to George H.W. Bush to get advice. George H.W.B sends a letter to George DeM and George DeSpy decides he should talk to a reporter but alas, about an hour before he is supposed to meet and share, he decides to put a shotgun in his mouth and pull the trigger.

Oh well nothing to see here folks. It’s nothing because “Oswald is our man” and “this case is cinched”.

That’s my CT perspective.

I could be wrong, but isn't most of Marina's WC testimony via an interpreter - so we're not really reading her words? I have a really hard time picturing Our Little Marina as being up to anything really nefarious in either the USSR or US. If she was, she deserves ten Academy Awards. I think I've posted this before, but it's an article with some excellent photos about Our Little Marina's English studies at the University of Michigan after the JFKA: https://heritage.umich.edu/stories/the-assassins-widow/.
24


I measured it (centerline of the model to edge of outside of the limo) at 3/4’ from the outside edge of the limo. That scales to be 18”.


I had previously ground away part of the model to simulate having the side of his torso against the inside edge of the side of the limo. Sorry about the sideways orientation. It’s apparently the image hosting site’s issue.




Here it is sitting in the limo.



Hey, could you find a Gumby doll and figure out how Govnr Connally was sitting on the jump seat and which way his legs were positioned and how he was likely holding his hat during the Z film sequence and try out Andrew’s twisted pretzel position for JC at Z270?
25
That's for the people hypothesizing a conspiracy to figure out. But since I'm in a generous mood, I'll give you a little help.

Physical evidence of one or more gunshots from a location other than the sniper's nest.

An eyewitness to a second gunman.

Wiretaps showing communications between the plotters and Oswald. Not an unrealistic expectation if you suspect the Mafia.

An informant.

That's just off the top of my head.

You'll have to take if from here.

All of those would be wonderful, but would they realistically be EXPECTED in a tight, compartmentalized Mafia hit of the POTUS - a hit that could literally destroy the organization if it went awry? Have a little respect for professionalism of the Mafia, willya? The American and Sicilian Mafia are estimated to have carried out thousands of successful hits over the past century. My expectation for the JFKA would be no more evidence than we have.

Alas, all of the Mafia-did-it books are not available on Kindle, so I'm going to have to load up on hard copies.

I know Larry Schnapf and Pat Speer lean toward the Mafia. I did a search on the Ed Forum and found what I expected: The Mafia gets little attention, and then only in the context of being a bit player in the elaborate and completely unbelievable LBJ, CIA and Everyone Else In the World Except Jackie and Hickey Conspiracy. The CT community simply cannot abide a conspiracy as dull and unsatisfying as the Mafia - just the Mafia.
26
Well I would suggest that if Oswald was the shooter and he was  part of a conspiracy, there were no plans for Oswald to be the patsy because surely there would have been a conspirator cameraman on the ground filming or getting a zoomed in photo of Oswald’s face as he stuck the rifle out the window.

That’s my LN / perspective.

So if it’s a conspiracy, then Oswald was not the shooter although he might have been used by the conspirators after they found out he was kind of a kook whom had taken pictures of himself with a rifle and revolver while holding magazines.

That’s my Centrist / Skeptic perspective
 
Now who would know about Oswald’s rifle and his photos and that he had shot at Walker and all kinds of things helpful to the WC narrative ?That  would be Marina, the innocent naive  USSR girl who had coincidentally met all the other CIA defectors and of course said nothing at all to her relative , a KGB officer no less.

But we are not allowed to question the veracity of poor little Marina , the one who in one WC testimony can barely speak English or understand it and then in other WC testimony is speaking English fluently and in great detail without a stumble. It’s a Miracle! Certainly the new husband was helpful.  However , George DeCIA spy , best friend of Oswald is depressed and finally reaches out to George H.W. Bush to get advice. George H.W.B sends a letter to George DeM and George DeM  decides he should talk to a reporter but alas, about an hour before he is supposed to meet and share, he decides to put a shotgun in his mouth and pull the trigger.

Oh well nothing to see here folks. It’s nothing because “Oswald is our man” and “this case is cinched”.

That’s my CT / Cynic perspective.
27
It's hard to tell with the circles covering JFK but I'm estimating you have JFK's head to far inside. With his side against the side of the limo, I estimate the centerline of his head would only be about 9 inches inside that. I base that on my on body which is broader than JFK. I outweigh him by about 70 lbs. My ballpark estimate is the centerline of JFK's head would be at most 2 ft. from the outside edge of the limo.

I think I have that same model car although mine is not stamped Luckydiecast. I can't quite make out what the script is identifying the manufacturer but it is stamped Made in China. I've had mine about 10 years. My experience with model trains tells me manufacturers will often sell or duplicate the molds among themselves and it is not unusual to see that same item produced by two or more companies. It's very easy to change the embossed label. Mine indicates it was manufactured under license number 24048 if that means anything. The jump seats on mine fold down and then can be pushed forward completely out of the way.



I measured it (centerline of the model to edge of outside of the limo) at 3/4’ from the outside edge of the limo. That scales to be 18”.


I had previously ground away part of the model to simulate having the side of his torso against the inside edge of the side of the limo. Sorry about the sideways orientation. It’s apparently the image hosting site’s issue.




Here it is sitting in the limo.

28
If that’s Lovelady then its doubtful that he and Shelly can do all they said they did and get back to the west.side rear door entrance in time to be the 2 unidentified men that Baker and Truly met 50 secs later at the rear elevators 1st floor.

But it can’t be Oswald there on the steps 20
sec post shots either because everyone has been gradually led to believe that the Altgens 6 photo at Z255 must be Lovelady even though no one has replicated that weird position and photograph it such that the lower shirt sleeve (with no hand !?) appears IN FRONT of whom ever the black guy is standing at the base of the steps. ( it’s either Roy Lewis or the big guy named Carl something).

    I agree. That was Not Lovelady & Shelley that were back by the freight elevator when Truly and Baker were back there. There is Nothing to support that claim.
   
29
That's a fair perspective - certainly more balanced than John's. But my God, there are at least 100 news stories every year involving multiple murders that are factually more ghastly than the JFKA. I read them, factor them into my perspective on human nature and what humans are capable of, and move on. I do think you grossly overstate the case in terms of Oswald letting a genie out of the bottle. There were surprisingly ghastly crimes long before Oswald, and the 1970's and 1980's looked nothing like today in terms of what you're describing. I think the near-hell we're living in today is due to factors much more recent than the JFKA. John's suggestion was that there is something illegitimate about anyone who is interested in the JFKA for any reason other than "JFK angst" and visceral hatred of Oswald. As stated, I'm very interested in Oswald the man and can have empathy for him without minimizing his actions. I can also be interested in the JFKA simply as a whodunnit and opportunity to exercise my brain, all of which I believe to be entirely legitimate. I actually think that the attitudes John expresses are an impediment to thinking critically about the case.

The critical thinking has been done countless times over the years to expose the fallacies of all CT objections to the conclusions of the WC. The questions the LNs pose to the CTs are questions they should have asked themselves but rarely if ever do.
30
At the very least, Oswald murdered two people in cold blood. Regardless of who they were, double homicide is a despicable act.  His actions also had longstanding cultural implications in my opinion that remain with us today.  He let the genie out of the bottle that every angry nut can take a gun and make is mark.  School shooting, mass shootings, other assassinations, and the security state that presidents must now live in can all be traced back to Nov. 22.  The merits or lack thereof of JFK have nothing to do with that.  The Camelot myth was a product of leftist revisionist history but that doesn't minimize the harm.

BRAVO!!!
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 10