JFK Assassination Forum

JFK Assassination Discussion & Debate => JFK Assassination Discussion & Debate => Topic started by: Vincent Baxter on June 21, 2021, 09:06:43 PM

Title: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Vincent Baxter on June 21, 2021, 09:06:43 PM
I recently read a book about the Orville Nix movie and it mentioned an old documentary from the 1980s entitled 'The Day The Dream Died' which I found on YouTube and thought I'd watch (Click here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63FjqTDeajY&list=PLFD58F582EA9F40AD (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63FjqTDeajY&list=PLFD58F582EA9F40AD) if you feel like wasting an hour watching it).

Amongst the numerous outdated and ill informed subjects mentioned it showed footage of the crowd running towards the grassy knoll and proclaimed this as 'evidence' that there was clearly a shooter there. I've read this theory numerous times before and always found it quite a stupid reason. If true it must be one of the only events in history where men, women and children bystanders have all ran towards an alleged crazed gunman.
Maybe I'm just a coward but if someone was taking open shots and I'd just seen someone get half their brain blown out the last thing I'd do is run towards the direction of where I thought the gunman was. In some cases men dragging their children with them.
I've always wondered what the likelihood was that people intentionally lied about saying they thought the shots came from the grassy knoll in an attempt to look courageous rather than admitting they thought the shots came from elsewhere and that they were running to the knoll for safe cover because they were scared spombleprofglidnoctobunsless?

But anyway, that's just my own musing. What I actually wanted to post about was the topic of David Ferrie's library card which was mentioned in the documentary as being found in Oswald's wallet when he was arrested. It's something that I've read so many conflicting reports about saying it was or it wasn't. What is the official word on that? Was it actually found on him or not and if so, what was the explanation for it being there?

Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Gerry Down on June 21, 2021, 09:23:30 PM
I recently read a book about the Orville Nix movie and it mentioned an old documentary from the 1980s entitled 'The Day The Dream Died' which I found on YouTube and thought I'd watch (Click here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63FjqTDeajY&list=PLFD58F582EA9F40AD (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63FjqTDeajY&list=PLFD58F582EA9F40AD) if you feel like wasting an hour watching it).

Amongst the numerous outdated and ill informed subjects mentioned it showed footage of the crowd running towards the grassy knoll and proclaimed this as 'evidence' that there was clearly a shooter there. I've read this theory numerous times before and always found it quite a stupid reason. If true it must be one of the only events in history where men, women and children bystanders have all ran towards an alleged crazed gunman.
Maybe I'm just a coward but if someone was taking open shots and I'd just seen someone get half their brain blown out the last thing I'd do is run towards the direction of where I thought the gunman was. In some cases men dragging their children with them.
I've always wondered what the likelihood was that people intentionally lied about saying they thought the shots came from the grassy knoll in an attempt to look courageous rather than admitting they thought the shots came from elsewhere and that they were running to the knoll for safe cover because they were scared spombleprofglidnoctobunsless?

I think what happened there is that Curry, who was in the lead car, thought the shots came from the overpass. He ordered on the radio to get some men into the railroad yard. The police responded and ran there. When the people saw the police running into the railroad yard they ran up the grassy knoll to see what was happening.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Robert Reeves on June 21, 2021, 09:31:11 PM
So why did the people attempt to get behind the grassy knoll/fence?

What was the causation for this stampede of ''stupidity''.

Maybe they were just following several cops that appeared to be headed for the knoll/fence.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Richard Smith on June 21, 2021, 10:21:34 PM
From the Elm St. perspective, the Grassy Knoll would seemingly be the most likely place for the shooter.  It was in close proximity to where JFK was assassinated and appeared to offer potential seclusion to the assassin.  Given the sound distortions of the shots in that open area, it would be the most logical place to assume that is where the shots came from.  And once some folks started moving in that direction, others would follow sheep-like to see what was going on.  Of course, we know that the backside of the Grassy Knoll is wide open to half of Dallas and no shooter would have positioned himself in that exposed location or could have escaped.  It is the last place any assassin would have chosen.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Jerry Organ on June 22, 2021, 12:02:00 AM
So why did the people attempt to get behind the grassy knoll/fence?

What was the causation for this stampede of ''stupidity''.

Maybe they were just following several cops that appeared to be headed for the knoll/fence.

Haygood was the motorcycle officer who ran up the knoll to the rail-bridge:

    "When I first got to the location there, I was still on Houston Street, and in the
     process of making a left turn onto Elm Street I could see all these people laying
     on the ground there on Elm. Some of them were pointing back up to the railroad
     yard, and a couple of people were headed back up that way, and I immediately
     tried to jump the north curb there in the 400 block, which was too high for me to
     get over."

Haygood's run might have influenced some among the masses then coming into the open Plaza area from Main. Also the siren of the departing front of the motorcade would have been heard coming from the area beyond the Underpass.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Mitch Todd on June 22, 2021, 03:07:36 AM
I think what happened there is that Curry, who was in the lead car, thought the shots came from the overpass. He ordered on the radio to get some men into the railroad yard. The police responded and ran there. When the people saw the police running into the railroad yard they ran up the grassy knoll to see what was happening.
Or maybe it had something to do with Lawson making a fuss about Holland, Dodd, and the other railroad workers being on the overpass.

SS SA Winston Lawson, 12/1/63 report:
We were just approaching a railroad overpass and I checked to see if a police officer was in position there and that no one was directly over our path. I noticed a police officer but also noticed a few persons on the bridge and made motions to have these persons removed from over our path.

SS SA Winston Lawson WC testimony:
Mr. STERN. What were the instructions that you asked be given to the police who were stationed on overpasses and railroad crossings?

Mr. LAWSON. They were requested to keep the people to the sides of the bridge or the overpass so that-or underpass-- so that people viewing from a vantage point like that would not be directly over the President's car so that they could either inadvertently knock something off or drop something on purpose or do some other kind of harm.

[...]

I noticed a few people along the right-hand side I can recall now, and more people on the right-hand side than out in the center strip median which is there, a grassy center strip. There weren't many people on the left at all. I recall thinking we are coming to an overpass now, so I glanced up to see if it was clear, the way most of them had been, the way all of them had been up until that time on the way downtown, and it was not. There was a small group, between 5 and 10 that looked like workmen. I got the impression, whether it was wrong or not I don't know, that they were railroad workers. They had that type of dress on. And I was looking for the officer who should have been there, had been requested to be there, and I noticed him just a little bit later, that he was there, and I made a kind of motion through the windshield trying to get his attention to move the people from over our path the way it should have been.
 
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Gerry Down on June 22, 2021, 03:10:53 AM
Or maybe it had something to do with Lawson making a fuss about Holland, Dodd, and the other railroad workers being on the overpass.

SS SA Winston Lawson, 12/1/63 report:
We were just approaching a railroad overpass and I checked to see if a police officer was in position there and that no one was directly over our path. I noticed a police officer but also noticed a few persons on the bridge and made motions to have these persons removed from over our path.

SS SA Winston Lawson WC testimony:
Mr. STERN. What were the instructions that you asked be given to the police who were stationed on overpasses and railroad crossings?

Mr. LAWSON. They were requested to keep the people to the sides of the bridge or the overpass so that-or underpass-- so that people viewing from a vantage point like that would not be directly over the President's car so that they could either inadvertently knock something off or drop something on purpose or do some other kind of harm.

[...]

I noticed a few people along the right-hand side I can recall now, and more people on the right-hand side than out in the center strip median which is there, a grassy center strip. There weren't many people on the left at all. I recall thinking we are coming to an overpass now, so I glanced up to see if it was clear, the way most of them had been, the way all of them had been up until that time on the way downtown, and it was not. There was a small group, between 5 and 10 that looked like workmen. I got the impression, whether it was wrong or not I don't know, that they were railroad workers. They had that type of dress on. And I was looking for the officer who should have been there, had been requested to be there, and I noticed him just a little bit later, that he was there, and I made a kind of motion through the windshield trying to get his attention to move the people from over our path the way it should have been.

Correct. This is what caused Curry to then think the shots had come from the overpass.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Charles Collins on June 22, 2021, 04:07:13 AM
The ambush from behind and up high was a smart military type of tactic that took the motorcade security personnel by surprise (as it was intended to do). As stated by others earlier in this thread, the overpass ahead of them was on their minds as the shots rang out. It is in my opinion just that simple.

 LHO was interested in the military at an early age. And was trained by the USMC in infantry tactics. He selected his location as he might have been educated to do in the military. It worked out successfully for him and, by design, also gave him a chance to escape.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Robert Reeves on June 22, 2021, 07:51:06 AM
(https://i.postimg.cc/7ZMyGSSV/ap-clip-reduced-cropped.gif)

And the odd behavior of the dark skinned male on the knoll steps that only turned and ran up towards the top of wall area ...  once JFK's head exploded in front of him. Would have made a lot of people suspicious about his actions.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Anthony Frank on June 22, 2021, 08:11:34 AM
Maybe people should read my thread titled: "What the People in Dealey Plaza HEARD is Important, not what they saw."

https://www.jfkassassinationforum.com/index.php/topic,3000.0.html
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Jerry Organ on June 22, 2021, 04:27:30 PM
Maybe people should read my thread titled: "What the People in Dealey Plaza HEARD is Important, not what they saw."

It's so easy to detect sound origin in an urban environment, military and cities around the world needlessly spent $100s of millions on Shot Locator Systems.

(https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5e4b4e783a237ebc39c3f9a5/5e57f98293c4a6d501c9d52f_Gunshot%20Sensors%20%26%20Cameras%203.JPG)  (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/41/Boomerang_3_Gunfire_Acoustic_Detection_System_MOD_45153048.jpg/427px-Boomerang_3_Gunfire_Acoustic_Detection_System_MOD_45153048.jpg)
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Denis Pointing on June 23, 2021, 03:11:26 AM
I recently read a book about the Orville Nix movie and it mentioned an old documentary from the 1980s entitled 'The Day The Dream Died' which I found on YouTube and thought I'd watch (Click here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63FjqTDeajY&list=PLFD58F582EA9F40AD (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63FjqTDeajY&list=PLFD58F582EA9F40AD) if you feel like wasting an hour watching it).
But anyway, that's just my own musing. What I actually wanted to post about was the topic of David Ferrie's library card which was mentioned in the documentary as being found in Oswald's wallet when he was arrested. It's something that I've read so many conflicting reports about saying it was or it wasn't. What is the official word on that? Was it actually found on him or not and if so, what was the explanation for it being there?

Hi Vince, this should clear it up; "Jack Martin also told bail bondsman Hardy Davis that he had heard on television that Ferrie's New Orleans library card had been found in Oswald's possession when he was arrested in Dallas. Davis reported this to Ferrie's employer, the lawyer G. Wray Gill. (In fact, no such library card was found among Oswald's possessions.) Ferrie subsequently visited both Oswald's former New Orleans landlady and a former neighbour about this report. Ferrie was able to produce his library card for FBI agents who interviewed him on November 27, 1963."
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Vincent Baxter on June 24, 2021, 12:00:01 PM
Hi Vince, this should clear it up; "Jack Martin also told bail bondsman Hardy Davis that he had heard on television that Ferrie's New Orleans library card had been found in Oswald's possession when he was arrested in Dallas. Davis reported this to Ferrie's employer, the lawyer G. Wray Gill. (In fact, no such library card was found among Oswald's possessions.) Ferrie subsequently visited both Oswald's former New Orleans landlady and a former neighbour about this report. Ferrie was able to produce his library card for FBI agents who interviewed him on November 27, 1963."

Ah, thank you. This is what I suspected.
Surely conspiracy theorists wouldn't make nonsense up solely to support their illogical accounts and to sell books, would they?  ;)
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Ray Mitcham on June 24, 2021, 12:12:38 PM
Strange that somebody (?) would report that Ferrie's library card was found in Oswald's possessions. I wonder who said that and why.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Walt Cakebread on June 24, 2021, 07:53:13 PM
I think what happened there is that Curry, who was in the lead car, thought the shots came from the overpass. He ordered on the radio to get some men into the railroad yard. The police responded and ran there. When the people saw the police running into the railroad yard they ran up the grassy knoll to see what was happening.

 (The spectators) ran up the grassy knoll to see what was happening.

That's correct....  The spectators wanted to see who the police arrested.....  Mr B..... Is a great Monday morning Q - back.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Denis Pointing on June 24, 2021, 07:55:46 PM
Strange that somebody (?) would report that Ferrie's library card was found in Oswald's possessions. I wonder who said that and why.

It was never reported on TV as claimed. So the whole thing must have been imagined by Jack Martin.
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Jerry Organ on June 24, 2021, 09:21:35 PM
It was never reported on TV as claimed. So the whole thing must have been imagined by Jack Martin.

And re-imagined by our Ray. :D
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Walt Cakebread on June 24, 2021, 09:32:39 PM
And re-imagined by our Ray. :D

If you'll do a little honest research you may find that there was a library card from the NO library that was not issued to Lee Oswald found in his wallet that afternoon....This fact has been carefully swept under the rug.   

If someone were to dig into this aspect, there may be some very revealing information exposed.

David Ferrie was involved in the murder of JFK....up to his ( fake) eyebrows   
Title: Re: Crowds running towards grassy knoll / Ferrie's library card
Post by: Jerry Freeman on July 06, 2021, 04:38:39 AM
I think what happened there is that Curry, who was in the lead car, thought the shots came from the overpass. He ordered on the radio to get some men into the railroad yard. The police responded and ran there. When the people saw the police running into the railroad yard they ran up the grassy knoll to see what was happening.
That's just wrong. The films show an immediate rush to the knoll.
From the Elm St. perspective, the Grassy Knoll would seemingly be the most likely place for the shooter.  It was in close proximity to where JFK was assassinated and appeared to offer potential seclusion to the assassin.  Given the sound distortions of the shots in that open area, it would be the most logical place to assume that is where the shots came from.  And once some folks started moving in that direction, others would follow sheep-like to see what was going on.  Of course, we know that the backside of the Grassy Knoll is wide open to half of Dallas and no shooter would have positioned himself in that exposed location or could have escaped.  It is the last place any assassin would have chosen.
"...the most logical place" -----Consider the source of this logic and then move on with actual logic.
Sheep like are these guys that have probably never been to Dealey Plaza but know it like the back of their hand. The far side of the knoll fence was the perfect place for an assassination...a parking lot with no one around. But then who can really know for sure?