Oswald's High School

[Matt Grantham]

Marguerite's maiden name was Claverie and the fact that Robert didn't remember it doesn't change that simple well established fact.

 I never said it wasn't Entering straw man territory

[Matt Grantham]

I'm a CTer but do not believe the Harvey and Lee (called by some, funnily, as Hardly Lee) baloney. I'd advise other readers to go to this very detailed and long thread on another forum. You'll find many of the silly, if not crazy, beliefs about this fictional caper including (non)photo alterations, sloping shoulders, and contrast(y) photos among other things.

http://educationforum.ipbhost.com/topic/23677-a-couple-of-real-gems-from-the-harvey-and-lee-website/?tab=comments#comment-348449

Sadly, because of the "kinder and gentler" nature of the above forum, many people who used to vigorously debate this nonsense over there have left or been banned - Thomas Graves and myself being two of them. The whole EF site has now become a vast echo chamber with little push back there and if there is any push back, you're either warned, are not read (they have a magical Ignore button there), or banned entirely.

 Maybe you are Michael But we do know that many folks like to pose as being sympathetic to the CT angle on many things so they can appear as an even more legitimate critic of when things have gone to far So far you have said nothing other than a story of being banned

[Matt Grantham]

Let's see if we can undo some of the misinformation in this thread. Frank Kudlaty never said a word to anyone about any confiscated records. At least not until he had a conversation with his friend Jack White who filled him in on the John Armstrong "Harvey & Lee" nonsense. Kudlaty then suddenly "remembered" the confiscated records. White tried to conceal the fact that he was a friend of Kudlaty in a discussion on the Education Forum, but Greg Parker got it out of him. The point is, if Kudlaty was so concerned about the "confiscated" records, why didn't he report it years before? Anyone interested in this can go to the EF and do a search or go to Greg Parker's ROKC site.


Robert Oswald was simply wrong about Stripling:


http://wtracyparnell.blogspot.com/2017/04/robert-oswald-and-stripling.html

 Pardon me if you just saying all the statements by these people are incorrect because you said so doesn't strike me as particularly insightful

[Richard Rubio]

Fascinating W. Tracy Parnell; as for myself, I enjoy reading these posts.

[W. Tracy Parnell]

Pardon me if you just saying all the statements by these people are incorrect because you said so doesn't strike me as particularly insightful

I think that my posts are just as helpful as yours, which seem merely to be regurgitations of information from other researchers including Armstrong and Jefferson Morley (in another thread). I am simply pointing out the problems here. Kudlaty never said word one about any confiscated records until he heard Jack White's (Armstrong's mentor for those who don't know) sales pitch. If I believed that the FBI did something untoward, I say something back in the day. That is a valid criticism IMO.

Robert Oswald was speaking to the WC and trying his best to reconstruct his life and his brother's life. He assumed that LHO attended Stripling. And, in fact, he would have started school there in September 1952 if Marguerite had not moved him to NYC in August of that year. So it was a logical assumption on his part but it was incorrect.

[Matt Grantham]

I think that my posts are just as helpful as yours, which seem merely to be regurgitations of information from other researchers including Armstrong and Jefferson Morley (in another thread). I am simply pointing out the problems here. Kudlaty never said word one about any confiscated records until he heard Jack White's (Armstrong's mentor for those who don't know) sales pitch. If I believed that the FBI did something untoward, I say something back in the day. That is a valid criticism IMO.

Robert Oswald was speaking to the WC and trying his best to reconstruct his life and his brother's life. He assumed that LHO attended Stripling. And, in fact, he would have started school there in September 1952 if Marguerite had not moved him to NYC in August of that year. So it was a logical assumption on his part but it was incorrect.

 I want to make sure I understand the inference before commenting further, you believe Kudlaty's statements should be discredited because he had not alerted someone earlier that the records at Stripling had been seized by the FBI

 As to your points about Robert Oswald, What exactly is supposed to be substantive about your claim? I try not to negatively characterize the posts of other's but I just fail to see what you're demonstrating other than you believe Robert Oswald was making an assumption or confused

[Michael Chambers]

  Can anyone tell me if the JFK education Forum allows for new members? I am having trouble finding a way to do so or getting a response from the administrators

I doubt it but a lot of the members here are a lot more conversant with EF than me.

However 5 years ago I tried to join and got the same "brick wall".

Also hand in glove is Greg Burnhams site "assassinationjfk.net", which openly offers you can join but the capta wont work and when you contact about it there is just a :brick wall". At least burham mailed me back explaining how there had been a sophisticated hack and he cant fix the capta. The EF and Him must have formed their own exclusive club I guess.