Lee Oswald The Cop Killer

[Tim Nickerson]

It's a mathematical impossibility that so many witnesses identify the same man yet disagree about just about everything else, like for instance the color of the jacket.

Is it really a mathematical impossibility?

[Bill Chapman]

Is it really a mathematical impossibility?

Not at all. In fact it would be more surprising if there hadn't been a variation in color perception amongst the witnesses. It's all in the eye cone variations between people.

[Bill Chapman]

As stated you're correct because.....wrong cabbie.

Cherry picking on steroids.

The totality of evidence rules out Whaley.

Even the best lawyers within the Commission couldn't make it work.

Whaley's ID'ing of Oswald rules you out. Totally.

[Bill Chapman]

It"s not about me.

We have Whaley on record stating, repeatedly, counting left or right, he picked the wrong guy.

Not my problem you can't deal with it.

Whaley said 2nd from his left, third from his right. That makes it a #2 touchdown in both instances. Other witnesses said #2. Whaley said Oswald was the guy he hauled to Beckley.

You're taking on water. Man overboard. Oswald would fry.

[Martin Weidmann]

Is it really a mathematical impossibility?

Not with the line up they had. They might just as well have placed a neon sign above Oswald's head.

But why not try it for yourself and do the math. Just gather a few family members or friends together and show them an event that only took seconds. And then have them tell you all about what they saw..... It's a fun game.

[Bill Chapman]

Comedy Gold.

Oswald was #3 in that that particular lineup according to the DP.

Who's taking water on?

LOL
The expression is 'taking on water', not 'taking water on'

And are you now claiming that Oswald was not the guy that Whaley hauled to Beckley?

Mr. WHALEY. No. 2.
Mr. BELIN. From the right or from your right?
Mr. WHALEY. From my left.

All you are accomplishing in this Whaley thing is tantamount to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic: Your fate is sealed no matter how much you thrash, splash & flail about.

[Bill Chapman]

Not with the line up they had. They might just as well have placed a neon sign above Oswald's head.

BILL CHAPMAN

[Martin Weidmann]

BILL CHAPMAN

This line up would have been just as "fair" as the one they actually had