Can anybody provide proof of a successful reenactment of Oswald's feat?

[Walt Cakebread]

Okay: That three empty cartridge cases were allegedly found by the so called snipers window.

Okay: That three empty cartridge cases were allegedly found by the so called snipers window.

I'll assume that you have used the word "allegedly" because there is good reason to doubt that there were THREE shells there when Mooney first discovered the shells....  And yes, I know that it is widely accepted that there were THREE shells there, but there is also evidence that indicates there were only TWO spent shells....And all of the documents that originated in the TSBD that afternoon state that there were TWO spent shells found. 

[Bill Chapman]

Okay: That three empty cartridge cases were allegedly found by the so called snipers window.

I'll assume that you have used the word "allegedly" because there is good reason to doubt that there were THREE shells there when Mooney first discovered the shells....  And yes, I know that it is widely accepted that there were THREE shells there, but there is also evidence that indicates there were only TWO spent shells....And all of the documents that originated in the TSBD that afternoon state that there were TWO spent shells found.

Assume what you must if it helps you get to wherever you're aiming.
And note that I quoted Freeman verbatim. He couched the question like that, not in a way that takes a conflicting position.

And call me whatever you want. I don't mind.

[Bill Chapman]

Three empty cartridge cases were allegedly found by the so called snipers window. What does that prove? You tell me.Duh...Oswald was dead. He did not need protection --she did.Go watch some youtube gun posts and if you see a video where someone is 'dry-firing' or pointing a gun and yelling BANG... link it and put it up for us.Do you have any guns? If so what kind.. and do you dry-fire them or live fire them? Both? Neither?

Do you have any guns? If so what kind..
>Biceps

[Martin Weidmann]

Assume what you must if it helps you get to wherever you're aiming.
And note that I quoted Freeman verbatim. He couched the question like that, not in a way that takes a conflicting position.

And call me whatever you want. I don't mind.

Assume what you must if it helps you get to wherever you're aiming.

Says the guy who made one assumption after another to get a 34.8" rifle into a 27" paper bag.   

[Bill Chapman]

Assume what you must if it helps you get to wherever you're aiming.

Says the guy who made one assumption after another to get a 34.8" rifle into a 27" paper bag.   

Information has it that the gun bag was 38"
Not aware of any assumptions attached to that

[John Iacoletti]

The WC knew he had been dryfiring. They had analyzed CE 543.

What possible analysis of an expended rifle shell could tell you who operated a rifle containing it?

[John Iacoletti]

Information has it that the gun bag was 38"
Not aware of any assumptions attached to that

Assumption attached to that: “gun bag”.