Buell Wesley Frazier

[John Iacoletti]

Oswald lied Frazier about what was in the sack and Oswald lied about where is package was in Fraziers car.

So you claim.  Proving that is another matter.

[John Mytton]

So you claim.  Proving that is another matter.

Not my claim and if Frazier's word isn't good enough for you then yeah sure throw him under the bus too, that seems to be your modus operandi!



JohnM

[John Iacoletti]

Not my claim and if Frazier's word isn't good enough for you then yeah sure throw him under the bus too, that seems to be your modus operandi!

I didn't throw Frazier under the bus.  Frazier never said Oswald lied, you did.  You're the one throwing him under the bus with your "mistaken" song and dance.  He said it wasn't the same bag.

And you're a hypocrite too, given the cavalcade of witnesses that you and your ilk regularly throw under the bus:

Arnold Rowland
Roger Craig
Carolyn Walther
Jean Hill
Vickie Adams
Julia Ann Mercer
Acquilla Clemons
Bernard Haire
Sylvia Odio
O.P. Wright
Bardwell Odum
Seth Kantor
Butch Burroughs
W.R. (Dub) Stark
Louis Cortinas
Tom Mullins, Emmett Hollingshead, and J.B. "Shorty" Lewis
James A. Andrews
T. F. White
Fred Moore
John Elrod
Jack Davis
Paul O?Connor
Floyd Riebe
Jerrol Custer
James Curtis Jenkins
Dennis David
Saundra Spencer
Dean Andrews
Carolyn Arnold
Janet Conforto
Charles Crenshaw
Marita Lorenz
Nelson Delgado
Edwin Walker
Nancy Lee Fenner
Albert Bogard
Richard Randolph Carr
Waggoner Carr
Kenneth Croy
John Manchester
Perry Russo
Edith Whitworth
Esther Mash
Delphine Roberts
Roy Eugene Vaughn

Just to name a few.

[Bill Brown]

Why are you asking for "anyone" to prove a claim that nobody made?  That's exactly what a strawman is, whether you understand it or not.

I asked if anyone can show that Bookhout was lying when he stated (in his report) that Randle told him the bag was three feet long.  That is a question and is far from a straw man argument.

[Bill Brown]

It's truly sad and scary what you think passes for logic.

Logic, as in... your claim that the "click" that was heard by many during the theater scuffle... could have been a theater seat?

[Martin Weidmann]

Why are you asking for "anyone" to prove a claim that nobody made?  That's exactly what a strawman is, whether you understand it or not.

Precisely, because if nobody can prove that Bookhout was lying (the only person who actually could have done that was the late Linnie Mae Randle) the silly argument would be that Bookhout must have been telling the truth because nobody can prove he didn't.

That is the only plausible reason for asking such a pathetic question in the first place.

[Bill Brown]

Precisely, because if nobody can prove that Bookhout was lying (the only person who actually could have done that was the late Linnie Mae Randle) the silly argument would be that Bookhout must have been telling the truth because nobody can prove he didn't.

That is the only plausible reason for asking such a pathetic question in the first place.

Speaking of straw man...

I have never stated that Bookhout must be telling the truth since no one can prove he was lying in his report.

I have asked if anyone can prove that Bookhout was lying.  Since you obviously cannot, it must be taken into consideration that his report stated that Randle estimated that the bag was three feet long.  THAT is the reason for me asking my "pathetic" question in the first place.