JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion & Debate > JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion And Debate
Summary of Some of the Major Problems with the JFK Medical Evidence
John Corbett:
--- Quote from: Paul J Cummings on Yesterday at 05:13:43 PM ---Perhaps instead of giving your opinion on MTG's research you will counter research of your own?
--- End quote ---
It would be charitable to call MTG's clusters "research".
Paul J Cummings:
Thanks for proving my point.
--- Quote from: John Corbett on Yesterday at 05:25:55 PM ---It would be charitable to call MTG's clusters "research".
--- End quote ---
Lance Payette:
--- Quote from: Paul J Cummings on Yesterday at 05:13:43 PM ---Perhaps instead of giving your opinion on MTG's research you will counter research of your own?
--- End quote ---
I hate to bust your burble, but MTG doesn't do research. He collects conspiracy nuggets and weaves them into hyperbolic conspiracy narratives like a crazed CT televangelist. The JFKA medical evidence has been subjected to enough discussion and debate by genuine medical, ballistic and forensic experts for six decades, and they and their fans have arrived at such a bewildering mishmash of hopelessly conflicting interpretations, that one can weave almost any narrative one wishes. Some of it is interesting and genuinely puzzling, but in the absence of any consensus and any medical expertise on my part I decline to assemble hyperbolic narratives telling others what is IMPOSSIBLE! UNDENIABLE! UNSOLVABLE! MUST BE BELIEVED! and CAN'T BE REFUTED!!! "Research," as MTG's hero Paul Hoch himself pointed out, consists in working from primary source documents - not assembling dubious secondary sources and then compiling self-serving but fallacious appeals to authority.
Paul J Cummings:
Thanks for your opinion. Where's your counter research to dispute his?
Michael T. Griffith:
--- Quote from: Paul J Cummings on Yesterday at 05:13:43 PM ---Perhaps instead of giving your opinion on MTG's research you will counter research of your own?
--- End quote ---
Oh, yes! You hit the nail on the head!
Mark my words: They will do everything but provide any specifics in response to the facts I've presented. They will offer a myriad of excuses for their ducking and dodging, but they will never get around to engaging me on a single one of the facts I've documented.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version