JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion & Debate > JFK Assassination Plus General Discussion And Debate
Gunman in the pergola window...
Mitch Todd:
--- Quote from: Royell Storing on March 23, 2026, 03:32:45 PM --- "Whatever he thought it was"? Now you're getting into Bill Clinton territory. Please stop dragging this out.
(1) Witt testified that he was walking straight toward Elm St. (2) He ID'd himself as being in the photo showing him and The Cuban sitting on the retaining wall after the kill shot. (3) He testified something along the lines of, "We just sat down" following the kill shot. ALL of this clearly shows what section of the "Grassy Knoll" Witt was referring to. It helps to be familiar with the entire Witt HSCA Testimony.
--- End quote ---
You just argued that: a.) Witt claimed that he was on the grassy knoll and b.) that the Bronson film shows that Witt was not on the GK. I pointed out that he can easily be seen in the Bronson film standing in front of the Pergola, and that many people consider that the GK to be the grassy area north of Elm. By implication, Witt would have been on the knoll if the more expansive definition was used. Also by implication, the Bronson film is not proof that Witt lied or otherwise misrepresented his position.
Your response was "well, I define the GK to be...." But it's not about how you define GK, but how Witt would have defined the term. Is it really that hard for you to follow along?
John Corbett:
--- Quote from: Mitch Todd on March 24, 2026, 01:05:57 AM ---
Your response was "well, I define the GK to be...." But it's not about how you define GK, but how Witt would have defined the term. Is it really that hard for you to follow along?
--- End quote ---
It probably is.
Royell Storing:
--- Quote from: Mitch Todd on March 24, 2026, 01:05:57 AM ---You just argued that: a.) Witt claimed that he was on the grassy knoll and b.) that the Bronson film shows that Witt was not on the GK. I pointed out that he can easily be seen in the Bronson film standing in front of the Pergola, and that many people consider that the GK to be the grassy area north of Elm. By implication, Witt would have been on the knoll if the more expansive definition was used. Also by implication, the Bronson film is not proof that Witt lied or otherwise misrepresented his position.
Your response was "well, I define the GK to be...." But it's not about how you define GK, but how Witt would have defined the term. Is it really that hard for you to follow along?
--- End quote ---
There are NO Images at any point in time showing Witt/Umbrella Man standing on any "grassy area". That argument has absolutely nothing to support it. Totally ridiculous right out of the blocks.
Tom Graves:
--- Quote from: Royell Storing on March 24, 2026, 04:55:12 AM ---There are no images at any point in time showing Witt/Umbrella Man standing on any "grassy area." That argument has absolutely nothing to support it. Totally ridiculous right out of the blocks.
--- End quote ---
Dear Royell,
How many photographic images of that part of Dealey Plaza during that period of time are there other than Bronson's "quickie"?
-- Tom
Royell Storing:
--- Quote from: Tom Graves on March 24, 2026, 06:44:23 AM ---Dear Royell,
How many photographic images of that part of Dealey Plaza during that period of time are there other than Bronson's "quickie"?
-- Tom
--- End quote ---
My Dad used to tell my brother and me, "I'll work with you guys. I will Not work For you".
YOU need to do the research. Start by actually watching the entire HSCA Witt testimony and seeing the Image evidence presented to him at that hearing.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version