Progress... Have we made any ?.....

[Jim Hawthorn]

Oswald in the lunchroom at 12:25 is not an invention of LNers. They're just saying that IF Oswald was in the lunchroom at that time, it doesn't mean he couldn't have made it upstairs in time for the sgooting.

And you're the only one claiming Oswald would call off the assassination if he merely encountered someone on his way up. And Oswald "zoomed" back down. There's plenty ludicrous alright.

Show me where I said that he would call off the assassination. You miss the point. He simply wouldn't have placed himself in that position as a gunman (lone or otherwise) with minutes to go and people everywhere who could have testified that they saw him going up minutes before the shooting started.

[Walt Cakebread]

Show me where I said that he would call off the assassination. You miss the point. He simply wouldn't have placed himself in that position as a gunman (lone or otherwise) with minutes to go and people everywhere who could have testified that they saw him going up minutes before the shooting started.

Lee Oswald was in the 1st floor lunchroom when Jarman and Norman walked by, at about 12:26 ? 12:27 .... Jarman testified that they took the west elevator and arrived on the 5th floor at about 12:28.   

Lee was in that 1st floor lunchroom when they walked by, and they took the elevator to the 5th floor, so Lee would have had to have left the lunchroom after they were aboard the elevator...and then climb the stairs to the  6th floor.  He simply couldn't have been on the 6th floor at 12:30.

[Jim Hawthorn]

Lee Oswald was in the 1st floor lunchroom when Jarman and Norman walked by, at about 12:26 ? 12:27 .... Jarman testified that they took the west elevator and arrived on the 5th floor at about 12:28.   

Lee was in that 1st floor lunchroom when they walked by, and they took the elevator to the 5th floor, so Lee would have had to have left the lunchroom after they were aboard the elevator...and then climb the stairs to the  6th floor.  He simply couldn't have been on the 6th floor at 12:30.

Exactly. Even if an LNer thinks he could have gone up in that time (or with a 4 minute window) it's a ludicrous idea for the reasons I stated.

[Walt Cakebread]

Exactly. Even if an LNer thinks he could have gone up in that time (or with a 4 minute window) it's a ludicrous idea for the reasons I stated.

it's a ludicrous idea

LNer's thrive on ludicrous ideas......

[Bill Chapman]

it's a ludicrous idea

LNer's thrive on ludicrous ideas......

We thrive on facts, CoupBoy
And Jan6proud#boy wannabes

[Jim Hawthorn]

Anyone could have been walking up or down the stairs or using the lift at that moment
_ The attitude of an underachiever right there, ppl
   Better not take risks; something might go wrong
   FFS, Jim
 

Surely you don't think that he remained in that little room until 2 minutes before the (late) motorcade came by then went up to take a shot?

[Dan O'meara]

Oswald in the lunchroom at 12:25 is not an invention of LNers. They're just saying that IF Oswald was in the lunchroom at that time, it doesn't mean he couldn't have made it upstairs in time for the sgooting.

And you're the only one claiming Oswald would call off the assassination if he merely encountered someone on his way up. And Oswald "zoomed" back down. There's plenty ludicrous alright.

As all LNers know, the problem with Oswald being on the first floor around 12:25pm is that Arnold Rowland had spotted the man with the rifle on the 6th floor ten minutes earlier.