The First Shot

[Andrew Mason]

Let's add one more piece of ballistic gymnastics to your already goofy theory. JBC's was struck while holding his hat in his lap. For a bullet or even a fragment of a bullet to bounce off his wrist bone and fly over the front seat would be remarkable on its own. Then to have it fly over the windshield and strike the curb near Tague would take us into the realm of the bizarre.

I agree. A bullet striking the radius while his right forearm was on or near his lap and deflecting up over the front seat, let alone the windshield and then striking Tague, would not only be goofy and bizarre but it wouldn’t fit the evidence.

[John Corbett]

I agree. A bullet striking the radius while his right forearm was on or near his lap and deflecting up over the front seat, let alone the windshield and then striking Tague, would not only be goofy and bizarre but it wouldn’t fit the evidence.

So are you agreeing that Tague was wrong about being hit by the second shot?

[Andrew Mason]

So are you agreeing that Tague was wrong about being hit by the second shot?

No. I am agreeing that a bullet did not strike JBC’s radius while his right forearm was on or near his lap and then deflect up over the front seat.

[John Corbett]

No. I am agreeing that a bullet did not strike JBC’s radius while his right forearm was on or near his lap and then deflect up over the front seat.

Let me see if I got this straight. You have JFK hit in the back by the first shot and hit in the head by the third shot. You have JBC hit by the second shot, around Z270 if I recall. So if JBC was hit by the second shot and Tague was hit by the second shot, wouldn't they both have to have been hit by the same shot? Looks like you have painted yourself into a corner on this one.

[Andrew Mason]

Let me see if I got this straight. You have JFK hit in the back by the first shot and hit in the head by the third shot. You have JBC hit by the second shot, around Z270 if I recall. So if JBC was hit by the second shot and Tague was hit by the second shot, wouldn't they both have to have been hit by the same shot?

Yes. But I will give you a little hint: JBC’s right arm is not on or near his lap at z271.

[Dan O'meara]

Yes. But I will give you a little hint: JBC’s right arm is not on or near his lap at z271.

That's right Andrew.
As it has been demonstrated to you numerous times, JBC's wrist is way above where the bullet exited his chest at z271.
It is impossible for the bullet to have struck the top side of his wrist in this position.
Physically impossible.
As has been demonstrated to you on numerous occasions.

It is also physically impossible that JBC's radius was shattered by a blow from a bullet yet his hand/arm doesn't move a fraction of an inch in response to this blow.
When will you accept that your stillborn theory died a long, long time ago.
Denial is a super-unhealthy mental state.

[John Corbett]

That's right Andrew.
As it has been demonstrated to you numerous times, JBC's wrist is way above where the bullet exited his chest at z271.
It is impossible for the bullet to have struck the top side of his wrist in this position.
Physically impossible.
As has been demonstrated to you on numerous occasions.

It is also physically impossible that JBC's radius was shattered by a blow from a bullet yet his hand/arm doesn't move a fraction of an inch in response to this blow.
When will you accept that your stillborn theory died a long, long time ago.
Denial is a super-unhealthy mental state.

The harder he tries to save it, the deeper the hole he has dug for himself. We are seeing the China Syndrome at work here.