Hugh Aynesworth...Solver of the Kennedy Assassination

[Charles Collins]

Isn’t that what you’re doing with William Broyles? What’s the difference?

I didn't start a thread with the intent to discredit William Broyles. I pointed out some differences in what Hugh Aynesworth said in his interview with Larry Sneed compared to the article by William Broyles. And I pointed out that Larry's interview was done in a completely different format which was originally intended for education (vs commercialism for the magazine article. I didn't claim that Broyles was lying (Jerry does claim Aynesworth lied) I leave it up to the reader to decide if one of them is lying. Those are the differences.

[Jerry Freeman]

Again, don't count on everything written by William Broyles being accurate. Here is what Hugh Aynesworth said in his interview by Larry Sneed in "No More Silence":
"She told me that day that Oswald came running in while she was watching television and that she tried to talk to him about the President being killed. He didn't want to talk, so he went in, changed his jacket and ran out. She then saw him run off the porch to the left and that was the last time that she saw him. See, there's no mention of what she came up with later that a police car came up and honked and all that crap."

She did not come up with the police car description "later". Mrs Roberts testified under oath to the Warren Commission about the police car long before the Sneed book came out. If Mr Sneed chose not to include that...then perhaps it was he who was being deceptive. No more silence? How about another book called "No More Lies"?

[Jerry Freeman]

  I didn't claim that Broyles was lying (Jerry does claim Aynesworth lied) I leave it up to the reader to decide if one of them is lying. 

Wrong. I demonstrated where Aynesworth was ...untruthful

[Charles Collins]

She did not come up with the police car description "later". Mrs Roberts testified under oath to the Warren Commission about the police car long before the Sneed book came out. If Mr Sneed chose not to include that...then perhaps it was he who was being deceptive. No more silence? How about another book called "No More Lies"?

She did not come up with the police car description "later".

Aynesworth was describing his interview with Roberts on 11/22/63, as the first journalist there, just shortly after the police had left. Her WC testimony was much later.

Again, Larry Sneed wrote the following in his introduction to his book:

I decided to let the subject of the interview speak for himself or herself and allow the reader to evaluate for themselves the merit of each story and its significance to the assassination. ...  The advantage of this decision was that the entire interview would be included thus eliminating the taking out of context and manipulation of language which has been attributed to various theorists and assassination buffs bent on “proving” their theories.

[Charles Collins]

Wrong. I demonstrated where Aynesworth was ...untruthful

Scroll down to page 88 second column and we see ...
Lie..."Oswald's landlady told the Commission that she saw Oswald get on a bus."
Truth.. Oswald's housekeeper told the Commission that she last saw him waiting at the bus stop north of the rooming house.
Lie..."Then one year later she [the landlady still?] is saying she saw Oswald get into a police car."
Truth...Mrs Roberts [the housekeeper] always maintained that a police car had pulled up in front of the house and honked while Oswald was in his room.
Aynesworth states rather ironically that "people will say anything."

Your words... 

[John Iacoletti]

I didn't claim that Broyles was lying

Yeah, you kinda did when you said “don't count on everything written by William Broyles being accurate”, just because Aynsworth said something different to Sneed.

[Charles Collins]

Yeah, you kinda did when you said “don't count on everything written by William Broyles being accurate”, just because Aynsworth said something different to Sneed.

It was more of an indirect request for corroboration that Aynesworth was lying than a claim.