3 x 5 Index Card that is item # 14 On the List

[Walt Cakebread]

Because your completely made up story about when Latona got the magic palmprint has no evidence to support it.

Nope. Fritz didn’t hand over the alleged third shell until 11/27.

Walt wrote:...."This listing of just TWO spent shells alone, and by itself, indicates that this document ( evidence inventory list) was created at a time when there were only TWO spent shells in evidence.....  And that time was the evening of 11 / 22/ 63."

John argued;... Nope. Fritz didn’t hand over the alleged third shell until 11/27.

Yes that's correct John.....so you should have wrote...  Yes, you're right, there were only two spent shells turned over to the FBI at midnight 11 / 22 /63 and Fritz didn’t hand over the alleged third shell until 11/27

[John Iacoletti]

Yes that's correct John.....so you should have wrote...  Yes, you're right, there were only two spent shells turned over to the FBI at midnight 11 / 22 /63 and Fritz didn’t hand over the alleged third shell until 11/27

But you were arguing that the first evidence list had to be written on 11/22 because that was the only day that there were only 2 shells in evidence. But that’s wrong. There were only 2 shells in evidence between 11/22 and 11/27.

[Walt Cakebread]

But you were arguing that the first evidence list had to be written on 11/22 because that was the only day that there were only 2 shells in evidence. But that’s wrong. There were only 2 shells in evidence between 11/22 and 11/27.

But the only day between 11/21 and 11/27 in which evidence was turned over that required an inventory was 11 /22......  According to the altered photo copy evidence was released to the FBI on 11-22-63 and 11-26-63 .

I'm sorry I can't direct you to the FBI photos of the spent rifle shells that were taken on 11/22/63.... But perhaps you've seen then....The photos show two spent shells on a desk with a placard that identifies the shells and the date.

[Walt Cakebread]

But you were arguing that the first evidence list had to be written on 11/22 because that was the only day that there were only 2 shells in evidence. But that’s wrong. There were only 2 shells in evidence between 11/22 and 11/27.

John,   I specifically stated that  item number 9 on the list, ( the TWO spent shells ) was just one of several indicators that indicate that the original evidence list "A" was typed up on the evening of 11 / 22 /63.   

So let's take another item .....Item number one on the list "A" simply describes the rifle as an "Italian Rifle " ....  On the evening of 11/22 that's all they knew about the rifle....but by Saturday Morning they learned that the rifle was called a "Carcano carbine" ....and that information is added to the altered photo copy "B"....

and here's another ....on the original list "A" item number 6 is the S&W revolver.....The entry says .....1   .38 cal pistol, 2" barrel. 

But on the altered copy"B" of the original list that number 6 entry says... .38 cal pistol, 2" barrel, S&W, Rev. sandblast finish, brown wooden handles ser. #510210.
rel to FBi agent 1-22-63 and again 11-26-63.      NOTICE.....[b]rel to FBI agent 1-22-63[/b]   And sure enough the pistol IS listed on the evidence list of the evidence that was released to the FBI on 11 / 22 / 63....

Is this too difficult for you to understand, John ?

[John Iacoletti]

Yes, I’ve seen the photo.

The problem with this argument is that the evidence list in question says nothing about being a list of evidence being turned over to the FBI. It’s just a list of items labeled “evidence”.

[Walt Cakebread]

Yes, I’ve seen the photo.

The problem with this argument is that the evidence list in question says nothing about being a list of evidence being turned over to the FBI. It’s just a list of items labeled “evidence”.

The altered list "B" says...
1 .38 cal pistol, 2" barrel,S&W Rev. sandblast finish, brown wooden handles ser.# 510210 .Rel to FBI agent 11-22-63 and again 11-26-63.

Released to an FBI agent on 11-22-63 .....  The revolver was item number six on the list .....and the 3 X 5 index card was item number 14.

[John Iacoletti]

That just helps make my point. If the whole thing was a list of evidence released to the FBI at the same time, there would be no need to make that annotation specifically on the “pistol” (which was actually a revolver).