Common Ground?

[John Iacoletti]

Not much.  You have two opposing approaches to the evidence.  Those that believe you can derive conclusions from making logical inferences from the facts and evidence and those who don't. 

You have two opposing approaches to the evidence.  Those that believe that wild-ass speculations are ?logical inferences? and those who don't.

[Duncan MacRae]

Repeat..... show me where you think the inside face is in a solid cylinder.

 https://www.reference.com/math/many-faces-cylinder-c94b7f73ecbe3745
Quote
"A cylinder has three faces or individual surfaces. It is a tube-shaped object that is solid on both ends, rather than hollow. It has one face on each end of the cylinder and a third face that wraps continuously around its shaft."

I have answered your question already.

https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/inside
Quote [usually in singular] "The inner side or surface of something"

[Ray Mitcham]

I have answered your question already.

Where?

I would sooner believe mathematicians.


Lee Kleir, PhD Electrical Engineering and Computer Science & Girls, The University of Texas at Austin (1976)

Originally Answered: In number how many sides does a cylinder have?
"A cylinder has 1 side which wraps around circular areas in the two ends. If the ends are enclosed then there are 2 circular sides for a total of 3 sides, two of which are flat circles and one curved side."


or....

"If it's a solid cylinder then it has three - a circular face at each end and a single surface that goes all the way round the middle which can be 'opened up' as a rectangle

If the cylinder is hollow (technically a tube) then it has two faces - an inner one and an outer one."

[Duncan MacRae]

Where?

I would sooner believe mathematicians.

Lee Kleir, PhD Electrical Engineering and Computer Science & Girls, The University of Texas at Austin (1976)

Originally Answered: In number how many sides does a cylinder have?
"A cylinder has 1 side which wraps around circular areas in the two ends. If the ends are enclosed then there are 2 circular sides for a total of 3 sides, two of which are flat circles and one curved side."


or....

"If it's a solid cylinder then it has three - a circular face at each end and a single surface that goes all the way round the middle which can be 'opened up' as a rectangle

If the cylinder is hollow (technically a tube) then it has two faces - an inner one and an outer one."

In an earlier post.

Like a Black Hole, the Solid Cylinder has an inside but it can never be seen by the naked eye.

Your Mathematician's logic makes as much sense as putting Harold Shipman in charge of Help The Aged.

[Ray Mitcham]

In an earlier post.

Repeatedly saying the cylinder has an inside, doesn't prove that it has a side (or face ) inside.

[Duncan MacRae]

Repeatedly saying the cylinder has an inside, doesn't prove that it has a side (or face ) inside.

If you inject a solid object with another smaller object and seal the injection point of entry, then, in order to escape from the inside of the solid object, the injected object would be required to pierce any point where the injected object touches the inside of any outer edge, ie, the inner side. 

[Ray Mitcham]

Not weally, Dennis, I'm just vewy cwever.

Let's put it slightly differently.  Every Scotsman has a face on the outside of his head. With your reasoning, he also has a face on the inside,  proving that all Scotsman are two faced. I'll settle for that argument over.

Q.E.D.