BWF and LMR may not have been the only ones who saw LHO with a bag on 11/22/1963

[Richard Smith]

Does it make sense for Oswald to "play a role" as the person who was going to attempt to shoot JFK to carry a package too short to contain the rifle?

So now you acknowledge that the flimsy paper sack was too short to contain the rifle....Thank you.   However, just as you WC apologists have argued for decades the sack contained a rifle ....And ignorant people have IMAGINED that it was true..... 

If Oswald is was unwittingly complicit in his own frame up as you suggest here, why not just carry the rifle in the bag that is found on the 6th floor? 
Mr Smith, You're like talking to an addled brain 7 year old.....  Lee Had no idea that JFK was going to be murdered....He was playing the same stupid game that he'd played at General Walker's house back in April....

I'm not going to try to explain anything more to you.. Who would be so stupid as too ask ....why not just carry the rifle in the bag that is found on the 6th floor?



Can you imagine a man carrying a rifle into a seven story building just a few hours before the POTUS is due to pass by that building?? He obviously couldn't have carried the rifle into the building where a dozen of his fellow employees were gathered waiting to go to work.   Do you think the police wouldn't have been there asking him questions by 9:00 am??  Don't ask me anymore questions....You're a waste of time.

Wow - this is brutal.  Like beating a defenseless animal with a club.  I never acknowledged that the paper sack was too short to contain the rifle.  That is implicit in your fairy tale.  I simply addressed the absurdity in your fantasy in which Oswald is complicit in a scenario to make him appear to the attempted assassin but for some inexplicable reason then carries a bag too short to contain the rifle!  If Oswald wants to give the appearance of being the attempted assassin that day, why would he take his lunch and curtain rods in a bag too short to contain the rifle?  Why not just take the rifle?  And the conspirators have to cover up and replace all that with the evidence that Oswald would have voluntarily have carried himself.  Good grief.  Someone carried the rifle into the TSBD since it was found there.  Why do you think someone else could do that but not Oswald?  Besides in your nutty scenario, Oswald wants to be the suspect.  That is why he carries a long bag to begin with.  You can't have it both ways suggesting Oswald was voluntarily taking actions to give the appearance of being the attempted assassin but suggesting he didn't want to act suspiciously.  If Oswald is complicit in his own frame up, as you stupidly suggest, there is no reason for all this subterfuge with curtain rods etc.  It's a simple and obvious point.  If you want to advocate this science fiction narrative, then accept the evidence that Oswald carried a long bag that contained the rifle.

[John Iacoletti]

If you want to advocate this science fiction narrative, then accept the evidence that Oswald carried a long bag that contained the rifle.

The problem is (and if there's one thing we can agree on, it's the silliness of Walt's "hoax assassination" narrative), that there is no evidence that Oswald carried a long bag that contained the rifle.

[Walt Cakebread]

The problem is (and if there's one thing we can agree on, it's the silliness of Walt's "hoax assassination" narrative), that there is no evidence that Oswald carried a long bag that contained the rifle.

I've never ever said that the 27 inch FLIMSY paper sack contained a rifle....Where did you get that absurd idea?     I HAVE said repeatedly that Lee was playing the same stupi game that he played at Walker's in April.....  Where he fired a bullet through Walker's window to make it appear that he had ATTEMPTED to shoot one of Castro's arch foes.......

If you can't see that Lee was using the same basic MO on 11/22/ 63 ..... There's little hope for you.

[Jerry Freeman]

     This is getting sillier with every post.   

[John Iacoletti]

I've never ever said that the 27 inch FLIMSY paper sack contained a rifle....Where did you get that absurd idea?

I didn?t say you did. That?s ?Richard??s absurd idea.

     I HAVE said repeatedly that Lee was playing the same stupi game that he played at Walker's in April.....  Where he fired a bullet through Walker's window to make it appear that he had ATTEMPTED to shoot one of Castro's arch foes.......

This, however, is your absurd idea.

[Walt Cakebread]

I didn?t say you did. That?s ?Richard??s absurd idea.

This, however, is your absurd idea.

Explain why you think the idea is absurd.....

[John Iacoletti]

Explain why you think the idea is absurd.....

There's no evidence whatsoever that either the Walker shooting or the JFK shooting were arranged as hoaxes to get Oswald into Cuba.  That's just a Walt fabrication.