Oswald in the TSBD just after the shooting

[Rob Caprio]

Roger Craig
Marvin Robinson
Helen Forrest
Roy Cooper
James Pennington

Thanks John. There's Randolph Carr too.

[Rob Caprio]

Back at ya, tough guy



Roger Craig


Marvin Robinson


Helen Forrest


Roy Cooper


James Pennington

You clearly seem clueless about most of the evidence in this case so why are you here? Just curious.

[Rob Caprio]

Point out where I ever said I was right about the evidence

At least you admit that you are NEVER right about the evidence.

[Bill Chapman]

At least you admit that you are NEVER right about the evidence.

Where did I 'admit' that

Unlike certain blowhards on this forum, I lack the ego and arrogance to claim I 'know' what happened.

[Oscar Navarro]

The so called "Sniper's nest" was behind the south window at the east end of the sixth floor.....  It did not extend deep into the room.. (only about three feet)  and it was only the width of one set of windows....(1/2 the set of windows)

However, I don't believe that a boundary has been solidly established .....

The tiny nook had been created as a place where a loafing worker could hide out of sight of the boss and smoke ( in a no smoking area) and snack .....Someone with a wild imagination thought it could be used as a place to plant a couple of spent shells .....and thus make it appear as the place where someone had fired a couple of shots at JFK.

And it just so happens that several people saw a sniper either shoot from that window, saw a rifle or what looked like a rifle being retracted from the window, three witnesses who were one floor below hear shots coming from right above them one of which heard the distinct sounds of shells hitting the floor above him and of the rifle bolt being operated. That's called a mass imaginary illusion. The one who is imagining is that one who refuses to accept that there was actually a sniper in the SN shooting at JFK.

[Colin Crow]

OK, let's discuss and debate. I think BRW had no reason to lie and neither did Jarman and Norman. I have posted my opinion on the subject already. The totality of all the statements of the Three Amigos (sounds much better than The Three Stooges) were covered in their testimonies before the Commission. I think relying on Arnold Rowland's testimony is foolish. I agree with your following statement "Williams went to the 6th floor to eat his lunch and watch the motorcade prior to joining Jarman and Norman on the 5th floor on the day of the assassination. Agree or disagree?" I won't be able to fully engage until Thursday night at the earliest as I have some commitments.

Ok. Waiting for your discussion and debate.

"The totality of all the statements of the Three Amigos (sounds much better than The Three Stooges) were covered in their testimonies before the Commission." Not sure what this means.....

I disagree with what I think is your premise. What the commission did was to concoct a story that suited the official outcome. This was compiled largely by Ball and Belin in their March trip to Dallas. The lies of the three were largely ignored. If you read my analysis there was no need to rely on Rowland, his observations were merely conformational.

You agree that Williams did go to the 6th floor, how about his first day statement?

He left the 6th floor ?about 10 minutes to 12? to break for lunch downstairs, ?I went backup on the 5th floor with a fellow called Hank and Junior I don?t know his last name?.

Was that essentially the same regarding his movements as those provided by Jarman and Norman before the WC testimonies?

[Bill Chapman]

OK, let's discuss and debate. I think BRW had no reason to lie and neither did Jarman and Norman. I have posted my opinion on the subject already. The totality of all the statements of the Three Amigos (sounds much better than The Three Stooges) were covered in their testimonies before the Commission. I think relying on Arnold Rowland's testimony is foolish. I agree with your following statement "Williams went to the 6th floor to eat his lunch and watch the motorcade prior to joining Jarman and Norman on the 5th floor on the day of the assassination. Agree or disagree?" I won't be able to fully engage until Thursday night at the earliest as I have some commitments.

The thing that's frustrating for me is why none of the 3 sought to investigate the sixth floor upon hearing shots from above them. Instead they run over to the west side windows. Not too bright.