Conspiracy of the Three Stooges

[John Mytton]

Do you think he was shown the Dillard photo at some point?

Shown by whom?

JohnM

[Colin Crow]

Seriously? You people absolutely crucify anybody who saw Oswald just ask Brennan or Givens and if Williams changed his story to say he actually did see Oswald in the sniper's nest then just tell me how that would go down?, perhaps Bonnie Ray was a touch more perceptive than you give him credit for.

JohnM

And what if it was not Oswald that he saw.......how would the events have played out in your view? Would Williams have come to Oswald?s defence?

[Colin Crow]

And a big shout out to the 130 guests currently viewing the thread.

[Howard Gee]

At this point only Howard feels that the proposal that the available evidence is not suggestive that the 3 witnesses did not collude in an attempt to protect Williams from the floor seats were associated with. I would point out that the evidence presented was available to the WC. Howard feels that it was simply a matter of some sort of common group mistake......sort of a reverse gorilla experiment effect where somehow a person is included in an event who wasn?t present.

Not exactly, Colin.

I think the initial statements in which two of the Stooges seem to mention BRW ascending to the 5th floor with them is just a mistake they made under a hectic confusing and stressful situation. The crux of their statements concerned what they saw and heard during the assassination, not the exact movements and whereabouts of each of the Stooges prior to the event.

BRW's locale and movements in the period preceding the shots simply wasn't important to them. What they definitely remembered was that BRW was with them when the shots rang out.

What I do find disconcerting is BRW claiming he ate his lunch downstairs. At least I think that's something he claimed. That bothers me.

The Stooges also said some other things that don't quite make sense to me, but I don't see anything sinister in it.

For example, immediately after the shots the Stooges went to the other side of the floor and looked out the window. I think part of the narrative has become they moved there to see the crowd in the area behind the building. Except there was no crowd assembled there immediately after the shots.

I think the Stooges actually ran to that end of the building as it afforded them a better view of the motorcade and it's rush towards Parkland.
 
I simply do not buy that in the scant harried moments spent on the 5th floor after the shots, that BRW's location before the shots was even a consideration.

I can't envision BRW saying something to the effect of 'I was on the 6th floor a few minutes before the shots, and I need you guys to cover that up'.

I'm pretty sure they were more concerned about what was ocurring at that moment and not where BRW was at 12:25.

I also find it unlikely that Jarman and Norman, if asked to, would readily agree to lie on behalf of BRW. They were just work acquaintances, not buxom buddies.

Can't buy into the Stooge conspiracy. The logistics and timeline just doesn't support it.

However, BRW's misleading (or at best, inaccurate) statements are an issue of concern. I can understand why he would want to distance himself from the 6th floor, but since he definitely wasn't a shooter, lying about being there before the shooting is sheer stupidity.
 
That being said, I don't believe BRW was involved in a conspiracy to murder JFK, or that the two other Stooges conspired to hide the fact that BRW ate his lunch on the 6th floor.

[Colin Crow]

I don?t think any of them were involved in the assassination either. As for their affidavits and statements we have to agree to disagee. Not with just me but every other poster in the thread it seems. Maybe we might event get some CTs posting their thoughts too.

[John Mytton]

And what if it was not Oswald that he saw.......how would the events have played out in your view? Would Williams have come to Oswald?s defence?

And what if it was not Oswald that he saw.......how would the events have played out in your view?

I don't think that Williams would have been allowed to live to be able to identify the guy because if this guy was willing to kill the President then BRW would have been less than nothing.

Would Williams have come to Oswald?s defence?

That's interesting if Williams managed to get away, saw Oswald arrested and subsequently realized that the guy he saw must have been the assassin then that's a conundrum that has no easy answer.

JohnM

[Howard Gee]

I don?t think any of them were involved in the assassination either. As for their affidavits and statements we have to agree to disagee. Not with just me but every other poster in the thread it seems.

Guess that makes me a lone nut.

Since we seem to agree the Stooge conspiracy would have been hatched before the Stooges arrived downstairs, and the Stooges are known to have been downstairs within a few minutes of the shots....

I need to ask, do you honestly believe BRW's whereabouts at 12:25 was a consideration or matter of importance to the Stooges during those few moments - or were they interested in getting downstairs and finding out WTF just happened ?